mojira.dev
MC-123025

Destroying moving blocks with TNT always drops the block

The bug

When a moving block (moving_piston) is destroyed by TNT, it will always drop the block instead of only dropping X percent of the time.

Related issues

Comments

migrated

Still in 18w50a.

migrated

It is intended, when a block is moved, it is turned into block 36 which has a blast resistance of 0. The fact that it drops 100% of the time is very usefull for many afk farms such as tree farms. Removing this behaviour will reduce possibilities.

migrated

That doesn’t make it intended, all blocks broken by explosion have a fracture chance depending on the explosion power to drop, this is most definitely an oversight

[Mod] Neko

@unknown: Can you provide a setup to reproduce this? I cannot reproduce in 18w50a, nor can the reporter of MC-141817 it seems.

migrated

I'm 99% sure this is WAI.

migrated

After checking again, you're right it's fixed, seems I was just incredebly lucky in my test to get them all to drop.

@unknown it was more than likely an oversight as this was different from every other block, but that's because the drop is determined via the NBT of the block, unlike all other blocks. This is not going to be closed as WAI unless you have a source from mojang of it being intentional, regardless of how sure you are.

[Mod] Neko

Resolved as fixed, thanks.

migrated

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Minecraft 1.12.2, Minecraft 17w49b, Minecraft 18w02a, Minecraft 18w19b, Minecraft 18w48a

Minecraft 18w50a

Retrieved