See attached screenshot
Expected behaviour:
Trident staying in hand
To reproduce:
Enter a multiplayer server,
Ask a player to hold up a trident and shift.
Observe how trident floats above hand
Related issues
is duplicated by
MC-125469
Trident doesnt fit to hand while sneaking
MC-125540
Player doesn't hold trident when sneaking
MC-125581
trident bug
MC-125897
Hello, I would like to report a Bugs that there is with the Trident. As soon as one crouches with the loaded Trident, the Trident flies in the hand
MC-129385
trident when we shift and when we want to attack with them
MC-131597
Incorrect placement with trident and bow
MC-131729
trident fly above your hand
MC-132920
Trident in the air
MC-138870
Channelling trident when using shift bug
MC-141300
Aiming the trident while sneaking causes it to float above the player
MC-144119
Flying Trident
MC-150167
Trident bug
MC-150289
Aiming trident while sneaking makes it float in 1.14 again
MC-151292
трезубец летает при присидании
MC-151688
Error with a trident
MC-159017
trident wont move with hand when you crouch
MC-160853
Trident Animation Issues
relates to
Attachments
Comments
migrated
migrated
I also have this problem in single player
CivetKitty
I tested this issue with other poses in MC-125748, but since it has been considered as a dupe, I'll explain it again.
This issue affects both single player and multiplayer, when holding the trident on the mainhand, offhand, and both, and while standing upright and swimming. You can also notice that duel wielding tridents on both hands makes the player lift both hands when attempting to throw it(MC-125337). While swimming, other items as well as the trident are affected by this hovering glitch.
migrated
Still an issue in 18w20a
migrated
Affects 1.13-pre1
migrated
Not fixed in 1.13-pre5
migrated
Still an issue in pre6
migrated
Affects 1.13-pre7
migrated
Affects 1.13-pre7 i confirm
Asteraoth
Confirmed for 18w30b
Asteraoth
Confirmed for 18w31a
Asteraoth
Confirmed for 18w32a
Asteraoth
Confirmed for 18w33a
Asteraoth
Confirmed for 1.13.1-pre1
migrated
Confirmed for 1.14.3-pre3
The issue is in the LayerHeldItem.renderHeldItem method (MCP 1.12.2 names). First the item is rotated by the arm rotation (translateToHand), and then if the player is sneaking it is translated 0.2 units downwards. However, this is 'downwards' relative to the arm rotation. When the arms are fully raised (aiming a trident when not swimming), the item is actually translated 0.2 units upwards. This can be fixed by applying arm rotations after the sneak translation.
migrated
Interestingly it seems this issue has been partially fixed (not sure exactly when, but testing in 1.14.4). Items are now positioned correctly while swimming, but the issue still exists for sneaking (the main focus of this report).
violine1101
As of 19w39a, the issue also happens if you're not charging the trident, see MC-162374.
wobst.michael
Appears to be fixed in 19w42a. Can someone please double check.
[Mod]Les3awe
Confirmed fixed in 19w42a.