[MC-1291] SMP - Minecarts and other ridden entities - Player Invisible When Getting Off / Players floating

When riding minecarts, with my friends on our server,
we can no longer see eachother when one leaves his/her minecart.

The players turns invisible for one another until one logs out and in again.

Linked issues

is duplicated by 14

MC-2174 A weird teleport glitch after someone gets off a minecart (please watch video) Resolved

MC-2517 Invisible players. [Minecart, Pig, Boat] Resolved

MC-2795 When using a boat elevator and the person gets out, they will always be invisible. Resolved

MC-4141 SMP On Boat and lag Server appears position mismatch of other Players Resolved

MC-5287 players and minecarts are being rendered at the wrong spot in MP Resolved

9 more links

Comments 14

Meta 2012-10-30T12:02:49Z

Even when driving from a location far away of other players (not streamed in) a single cart will drive and it will take time for the player to display.

Jentu 2012-10-30T12:12:15Z

This also happens on my LAN server. Though the player turns visible after a few minutes.

Meta 2012-10-30T12:14:43Z

Also after entering/exiting (can't remember) a cart sometimes the player displays at distanced places and walks through walls for a few seconds. I'll try to get that as video.

Mikael H. Karlsson 2012-10-31T21:05:04Z

Me and a couple friends experience this frequently on a server hosted by a friend off his computer. As soon as the player riding a cart moves out of your loaded chunks range, what is it 15x15 chunks, his model will often remain at that location. If you ride a cart up after him you'll see his model hovering in air without flapping there only to disappear after a little while or as you approach. But when arriving both players will usually not see each other until after a while or a relog.

Meta 2012-10-31T21:49:18Z

I can confirm what Mikael Hartwig-Karlsson wrote. Very annoying.

4 more comments

Tails 2012-12-09T17:40:38Z

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

Holger 2012-12-23T19:20:33Z

Still in 1.4.6. At high altitude I was able to observe the behaviour on short tracks. There I even got one minecart driving UNDER the track.

By the way: die player avatar is still sitting at the place where he started the ride (On long tracks the avatar mainly stuck somewhere standing along the track).

Rickard Åberg 2013-02-10T13:09:37Z

It exists in the snapshots too, last one i checked was 13w05b.
This was on Windows 7 aswell so it's not limited to Linux.

Sollace 2013-06-30T12:49:56Z

Players appear to be jumping around because the game uses the same packet to mount and unmount entities.

Ive made some changes that appear to fix the floating players. I haven't experienced any players becoming invisible though.

In EntityPlayer add the following method:

EntityPlayer.java

public void mountEntitySpecial(Entity par1Entity) {
        if (this.ridingEntity != par1Entity) {
            super.mountEntity(par1Entity);
        }
    }

In NetClientHandler change the handleAttachEntity method:

NetClientHandler.java (Before)

if (riderEntity != null) {
        ((Entity)riderEntity).mountEntity(riddenEntity);
    }

NetClientHandler.java (After)

if (riderEntity != null) {
        if (riderEntity instanceof EntityPlayer) {
            ((EntityPlayer)riderEntity).mountEntitySpecial(riddenEntity);
        } else {
            ((Entity)riderEntity).mountEntity(riddenEntity);
        }
    }

Torabi 2013-06-30T21:27:13Z

Ugh. That's kind of a kludge to get around the kludgy code that's already there. I tried to simplify that mess and ended up about where you did. Except it shouldn't be necessary with the changes to mounting in 1.6.1, or more specifically, the changes to unmounting. Since you no longer dismount by right-clicking the mount, but instead push the sneak key, EntityPlayer should no longer need to override mountEntity, and the check for "this.ridingEntity != par1Entity" should go right in NetClientHandler.HandleAttachEntity.

Sollace 2013-07-01T07:47:12Z

I see what you mean. I completely forgot they changed it. After testing in 1.6.1 the bug does appear to be fixed.

Rickard Åberg 2014-10-31T11:05:22Z

It is still a concern in the 1.8.1-prereleases, both with boats and horses... not sure about minecarts tho'.

galaxy_2alex 2014-10-31T11:50:58Z

Reopened, thanks

FaRo1 2016-06-10T19:44:40Z

Can't confirm in 1.10.