[MC-13262] Anvil refuses to imbue chestplate with enchantment

It's hard to detail precisely what this problem is, but to be very specific, I was playing on a custom map I found after digging around the net. While playing I happened to have a Golden Chestplate and Thorns Lv. 2 Enchanted Book in my inventory concurrently. After stumbling upon a Very Damaged Anvil, I decided to use it to imbue the chestplate with Thorns 2 from the book using the anvil. However, when I tried to do so, the anvil refused to process the enchantment. (Refer to first screenshot)

(NOTE: The anvil was very damaged and the golden chestplate's durability was slightly short of perfect.)

Additionally, I tried to replicate the bug on a Survival World by imbuing a similar Golden Chestplate (durability slightly less than perfect) with a Thorns 2 Enchanted Book. I used a Very Damaged Anvil, too, and this time, it DID work as expected (refer to second screenshot). While this could easily be a duplicate or a complete misunderstanding of anvil mechanics, can someone explain why in Screenshot 1, the process cannot be completed, but in the second one it can, although the circumstances are exactly the same?

Attachments

Comments 19

Anon Ymus 2013-04-06T14:19:20Z

Please force a crash by pressing F3 + C for 10 seconds while ingame and attach the crash report here.

Aligot Mash 2013-04-06T15:07:32Z

Will do in a few hours.

Aligot Mash 2013-04-07T02:09:55Z

In actual fact, how would sending a crash report help resolve the bug?
It's not that I'm not willing to send a crash report, I'm away from my computer and am curious to know.

Aligot Mash 2013-04-07T07:16:58Z

Well, regardless, here's the crash report:

---- Minecraft Crash Report ----
// I just don't know what went wrong :(

Time: 4/7/13 3:14 PM
Description: Manually triggered debug crash

java.lang.Throwable
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.l(SourceFile:1164)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.K(SourceFile:574)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(SourceFile:526)
	at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)


A detailed walkthrough of the error, its code path and all known details is as follows:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

-- Affected level --
Details:
	Level name: MpServer
	All players: 1 total; [bdw['benong171'/136, l='MpServer', x=651.24, y=65.62, z=-845.63]]
	Chunk stats: MultiplayerChunkCache: 441
	Level seed: 0
	Level generator: ID 01 - flat, ver 0. Features enabled: false
	Level generator options: 
	Level spawn location: World: (651,64,-843), Chunk: (at 11,4,5 in 40,-53; contains blocks 640,0,-848 to 655,255,-833), Region: (1,-2; contains chunks 32,-64 to 63,-33, blocks 512,0,-1024 to 1023,255,-513)
	Level time: 128481 game time, 169804 day time
	Level dimension: 0
	Level storage version: 0x00000 - Unknown?
	Level weather: Rain time: 0 (now: false), thunder time: 0 (now: false)
	Level game mode: Game mode: survival (ID 0). Hardcore: false. Cheats: false
	Forced entities: 102 total; [rh['item.item.sulphur'/1375, l='MpServer', x=679.25, y=52.13, z=-834.38], qg['Bat'/5709, l='MpServer', x=704.75, y=60.54, z=-858.79], qg['Bat'/5711, l='MpServer', x=703.92, y=60.00, z=-861.04], nf['entity.ItemFrame.name'/8, l='MpServer', x=522.94, y=88.50, z=-742.50], qg['Bat'/14818, l='MpServer', x=622.53, y=31.33, z=-776.56], sf['Skeleton'/29, l='MpServer', x=587.59, y=28.00, z=-851.59], nc['Experience Orb'/1608, l='MpServer', x=680.69, y=62.25, z=-841.56], sf['Skeleton'/22549, l='MpServer', x=704.50, y=67.00, z=-796.50], nc['Experience Orb'/1609, l='MpServer', x=680.72, y=63.25, z=-842.47], nc['Experience Orb'/1610, l='MpServer', x=680.69, y=62.25, z=-841.16], qg['Bat'/32, l='MpServer', x=589.40, y=28.67, z=-851.93], sf['Skeleton'/20890, l='MpServer', x=612.50, y=47.00, z=-859.50], ru['Creeper'/20618, l='MpServer', x=620.44, y=24.00, z=-844.00], qg['Bat'/36, l='MpServer', x=592.50, y=29.61, z=-853.50], rv['Enderman'/20619, l='MpServer', x=621.00, y=25.00, z=-845.59], sj['Zombie'/23339, l='MpServer', x=583.06, y=36.00, z=-879.38], sj['Zombie'/18973, l='MpServer', x=703.03, y=62.00, z=-863.47], qg['Bat'/16817, l='MpServer', x=605.84, y=48.93, z=-885.83], qg['Bat'/16818, l='MpServer', x=604.55, y=46.58, z=-888.81], sj['Zombie'/3320, l='MpServer', x=678.50, y=30.00, z=-794.50], qr['Squid'/55, l='MpServer', x=614.50, y=51.00, z=-804.50], sf['Skeleton'/19221, l='MpServer', x=623.50, y=26.00, z=-843.50], qr['Squid'/59, l='MpServer', x=619.16, y=52.34, z=-801.25], rh['item.item.dyePowder.black'/58, l='MpServer', x=620.50, y=53.13, z=-787.13], np['Painting'/76, l='MpServer', x=645.50, y=51.50, z=-923.94], rh['item.item.dyePowder.black'/57, l='MpServer', x=621.88, y=53.13, z=-787.13], ru['Creeper'/5987, l='MpServer', x=583.34, y=35.00, z=-877.53], np['Painting'/77, l='MpServer', x=640.06, y=51.50, z=-914.00], np['Painting'/73, l='MpServer', x=650.94, y=52.50, z=-914.50], np['Painting'/74, l='MpServer', x=646.94, y=51.00, z=-922.00], qg['Bat'/62, l='MpServer', x=621.53, y=33.78, z=-775.13], np['Painting'/75, l='MpServer', x=644.06, y=51.00, z=-922.00], qr['Squid'/7347, l='MpServer', x=620.50, y=52.02, z=-799.63], qr['Squid'/7346, l='MpServer', x=617.03, y=51.38, z=-797.47], qr['Squid'/7345, l='MpServer', x=614.09, y=52.38, z=-801.25], sj['Zombie'/8466, l='MpServer', x=690.50, y=27.00, z=-838.50], sf['Skeleton'/65, l='MpServer', x=618.84, y=86.00, z=-884.44], np['Painting'/76, l='MpServer', x=645.50, y=51.50, z=-923.94], np['Painting'/77, l='MpServer', x=640.06, y=51.50, z=-914.00], np['Painting'/78, l='MpServer', x=647.00, y=51.50, z=-911.06], qr['Squid'/24085, l='MpServer', x=614.25, y=51.16, z=-801.06], np['Painting'/73, l='MpServer', x=650.94, y=52.50, z=-914.50], qr['Squid'/24086, l='MpServer', x=620.50, y=50.00, z=-795.09], np['Painting'/74, l='MpServer', x=646.94, y=51.00, z=-922.00], np['Painting'/75, l='MpServer', x=644.06, y=51.00, z=-922.00], sf['Skeleton'/87, l='MpServer', x=652.47, y=50.00, z=-874.63], sh['Spider'/86, l='MpServer', x=642.59, y=50.00, z=-873.44], rh['item.item.dyePowder.black'/80, l='MpServer', x=647.81, y=48.13, z=-888.16], nf['entity.ItemFrame.name'/88, l='MpServer', x=648.06, y=66.50, z=-840.50], qg['Bat'/90, l='MpServer', x=649.08, y=30.76, z=-830.29], sf['Skeleton'/103, l='MpServer', x=677.09, y=74.00, z=-863.41], qg['Bat'/100, l='MpServer', x=657.29, y=28.91, z=-801.23], rh['item.item.rottenFlesh'/2537, l='MpServer', x=676.31, y=86.13, z=-870.16], ru['Creeper'/99, l='MpServer', x=661.50, y=51.00, z=-818.50], sf['Skeleton'/108, l='MpServer', x=685.50, y=106.00, z=-846.31], sh['Spider'/26316, l='MpServer', x=630.50, y=83.00, z=-877.50], sf['Skeleton'/8504, l='MpServer', x=630.28, y=56.00, z=-798.88], ru['Creeper'/14198, l='MpServer', x=620.00, y=32.00, z=-781.66], ru['Creeper'/106, l='MpServer', x=676.00, y=73.00, z=-863.56], ru['Creeper'/18557, l='MpServer', x=649.50, y=71.00, z=-798.50], sf['Skeleton'/23834, l='MpServer', x=627.50, y=81.00, z=-806.50], rv['Enderman'/112, l='MpServer', x=676.75, y=54.00, z=-850.69], sj['Zombie'/126, l='MpServer', x=697.97, y=76.00, z=-797.50], qg['Bat'/9335, l='MpServer', x=676.32, y=29.33, z=-793.52], ru['Creeper'/16376, l='MpServer', x=602.31, y=48.00, z=-885.31], sf['Skeleton'/14695, l='MpServer', x=644.31, y=27.00, z=-829.22], ru['Creeper'/20790, l='MpServer', x=621.69, y=31.00, z=-775.50], ru['Creeper'/20791, l='MpServer', x=622.50, y=31.00, z=-776.50], ru['Creeper'/20792, l='MpServer', x=620.75, y=31.00, z=-775.50], qg['Bat'/11287, l='MpServer', x=605.50, y=47.79, z=-887.38], sj['Zombie'/14234, l='MpServer', x=618.50, y=33.00, z=-774.50], sf['Skeleton'/26830, l='MpServer', x=672.50, y=28.00, z=-797.50], ru['Creeper'/6656, l='MpServer', x=576.50, y=67.00, z=-772.50], sf['Skeleton'/26829, l='MpServer', x=672.50, y=28.00, z=-795.50], sf['Skeleton'/26828, l='MpServer', x=676.50, y=28.00, z=-797.50], ru['Creeper'/21300, l='MpServer', x=646.50, y=26.00, z=-830.50], sf['Skeleton'/21301, l='MpServer', x=645.50, y=26.00, z=-829.50], ru['Creeper'/12760, l='MpServer', x=615.22, y=47.00, z=-862.22], ru['Creeper'/21303, l='MpServer', x=643.56, y=29.00, z=-828.00], bdw['benong171'/136, l='MpServer', x=651.24, y=65.62, z=-845.63], sf['Skeleton'/6693, l='MpServer', x=640.50, y=82.00, z=-885.50], ru['Creeper'/18008, l='MpServer', x=686.31, y=60.00, z=-894.56], ru['Creeper'/2361, l='MpServer', x=587.50, y=29.00, z=-853.50], sj['Zombie'/18004, l='MpServer', x=686.13, y=60.00, z=-895.56], ru['Creeper'/18006, l='MpServer', x=684.50, y=60.00, z=-896.50], qg['Bat'/181, l='MpServer', x=617.60, y=27.88, z=-840.68], sj['Zombie'/23256, l='MpServer', x=610.50, y=47.00, z=-855.50], sj['Zombie'/9960, l='MpServer', x=644.50, y=26.00, z=-874.50], ru['Creeper'/3873, l='MpServer', x=652.50, y=25.00, z=-800.50], sf['Skeleton'/10269, l='MpServer', x=613.50, y=53.00, z=-812.50], qg['Bat'/19590, l='MpServer', x=581.54, y=37.75, z=-880.46], sf['Skeleton'/16222, l='MpServer', x=587.50, y=29.00, z=-848.88], sj['Zombie'/15735, l='MpServer', x=623.50, y=33.00, z=-776.50], sj['Zombie'/25681, l='MpServer', x=620.50, y=26.00, z=-839.50], rv['Enderman'/25680, l='MpServer', x=622.50, y=26.00, z=-840.50], sj['Zombie'/24204, l='MpServer', x=687.50, y=27.00, z=-837.09], qg['Bat'/19593, l='MpServer', x=582.69, y=35.00, z=-877.66], qg['Bat'/19592, l='MpServer', x=580.58, y=37.25, z=-876.53], sf['Skeleton'/19876, l='MpServer', x=685.09, y=62.00, z=-890.50], sj['Zombie'/16963, l='MpServer', x=612.50, y=47.00, z=-857.50], sf['Skeleton'/10272, l='MpServer', x=619.59, y=47.00, z=-861.06], np['Painting'/78, l='MpServer', x=647.00, y=51.50, z=-911.06]]
	Retry entities: 0 total; []
Stacktrace:
	at bdt.a(SourceFile:282)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.b(SourceFile:1881)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(SourceFile:535)
	at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)

-- System Details --
Details:
	Minecraft Version: 1.5.1
	Operating System: Windows 7 (amd64) version 6.1
	Java Version: 1.7.0_06, Oracle Corporation
	Java VM Version: Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM (mixed mode), Oracle Corporation
	Memory: 174690160 bytes (166 MB) / 470024192 bytes (448 MB) up to 954466304 bytes (910 MB)
	JVM Flags: 2 total; -Xms512m -Xmx1024m
	AABB Pool Size: 1169 (65464 bytes; 0 MB) allocated, 2 (112 bytes; 0 MB) used
	Suspicious classes: IWrUpdater, Config, WrUpdaterSmooth, ...]
	IntCache: cache: 0, tcache: 0, allocated: 0, tallocated: 0
	LWJGL: 2.4.2
	OpenGL: GeForce GT 630M/PCIe/SSE2 GL version 4.2.0, NVIDIA Corporation
	Is Modded: Very likely; Jar signature invalidated
	Type: Client (map_client.txt)
	Texture Pack: Default
	Profiler Position: N/A (disabled)
	Vec3 Pool Size: 582 (32592 bytes; 0 MB) allocated, 11 (616 bytes; 0 MB) used

MiiNiPaa 2013-04-07T07:22:39Z

Crash reports contain info on internal gamestate which may be helpful.
They are required for all bugreports so if dev will need an error report, he will already have one.

9 more comments

Mustek 2013-04-07T13:35:59Z

This ticket is invalid as it relates to a modded or 3rd party client/server.

Any non-standard client/server build needs to be taken up with the appropriate team, not Mojang.
Any plugin issues need to be addressed to the plugin creator.
This site is for addressing issues related to the base unmodded MineCraft.

Aligot Mash 2013-04-07T13:40:48Z

Resolved invalid. Acceptable; however, the only mod on the client was Optifine. If the bug is replicable on the same map using the same specifications with a base client, would it validate the bug? I might be able to experiment with that by forcing an update.

Mustek 2013-04-07T13:43:50Z

If you are able to reproduce the same bug with an unmodded client, and provide a forced crash with it, I can reopen this issue again.

Mustek 2013-04-07T14:04:33Z

Hmm, could you press F3+H ingame, this will toggle Item IDs in their tooltips, then take a screenshot of what it shows on the golden chestplate?

Aligot Mash 2013-04-07T14:07:25Z

Sure; but while I'm at it, here is the new crash report (bug still persists).

Aligot Mash 2013-04-07T14:08:12Z

---- Minecraft Crash Report ----
// Surprise! Haha. Well, this is awkward.

Time: 4/7/13 10:06 PM
Description: Manually triggered debug crash

java.lang.Throwable
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.l(SourceFile:1164)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.K(SourceFile:574)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(SourceFile:526)
	at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)


A detailed walkthrough of the error, its code path and all known details is as follows:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

-- Affected level --
Details:
	Level name: MpServer
	All players: 1 total; [bdw['benong171'/44, l='MpServer', x=645.54, y=50.62, z=-912.40]]
	Chunk stats: MultiplayerChunkCache: 441
	Level seed: 0
	Level generator: ID 01 - flat, ver 0. Features enabled: false
	Level generator options: 
	Level spawn location: World: (651,64,-843), Chunk: (at 11,4,5 in 40,-53; contains blocks 640,0,-848 to 655,255,-833), Region: (1,-2; contains chunks 32,-64 to 63,-33, blocks 512,0,-1024 to 1023,255,-513)
	Level time: 2921 game time, 2921 day time
	Level dimension: 0
	Level storage version: 0x00000 - Unknown?
	Level weather: Rain time: 0 (now: false), thunder time: 0 (now: false)
	Level game mode: Game mode: survival (ID 0). Hardcore: false. Cheats: false
	Forced entities: 30 total; [rh['item.item.dyePowder.black'/2441, l='MpServer', x=658.25, y=49.13, z=-880.31], qg['Bat'/8, l='MpServer', x=567.57, y=42.37, z=-848.64], qg['Bat'/9, l='MpServer', x=582.07, y=35.74, z=-877.56], qg['Bat'/11, l='MpServer', x=590.93, y=28.83, z=-852.33], qg['Bat'/12, l='MpServer', x=590.46, y=29.94, z=-854.21], qg['Bat'/13, l='MpServer', x=590.13, y=27.76, z=-851.95], qg['Bat'/14, l='MpServer', x=592.80, y=28.84, z=-850.46], qg['Bat'/15, l='MpServer', x=621.86, y=26.47, z=-842.19], qg['Bat'/4150, l='MpServer', x=579.52, y=38.78, z=-875.68], np['Painting'/25, l='MpServer', x=650.94, y=52.50, z=-914.50], np['Painting'/27, l='MpServer', x=644.06, y=51.00, z=-922.00], np['Painting'/26, l='MpServer', x=646.94, y=51.00, z=-922.00], np['Painting'/29, l='MpServer', x=640.06, y=51.50, z=-914.00], np['Painting'/28, l='MpServer', x=645.50, y=51.50, z=-923.94], np['Painting'/31, l='MpServer', x=644.00, y=51.50, z=-911.06], np['Painting'/30, l='MpServer', x=647.00, y=51.50, z=-911.06], rh['item.item.seeds'/34, l='MpServer', x=651.16, y=49.13, z=-863.88], qg['Bat'/2957, l='MpServer', x=641.73, y=26.70, z=-875.64], qr['Squid'/32, l='MpServer', x=645.47, y=48.00, z=-887.50], nf['entity.ItemFrame.name'/36, l='MpServer', x=648.06, y=66.50, z=-840.50], qg['Bat'/42, l='MpServer', x=681.26, y=61.27, z=-896.27], np['Painting'/25, l='MpServer', x=650.94, y=52.50, z=-914.50], np['Painting'/31, l='MpServer', x=644.00, y=51.50, z=-911.06], np['Painting'/30, l='MpServer', x=647.00, y=51.50, z=-911.06], qg['Bat'/1538, l='MpServer', x=605.28, y=48.14, z=-888.41], bdw['benong171'/44, l='MpServer', x=645.54, y=50.62, z=-912.40], np['Painting'/28, l='MpServer', x=645.50, y=51.50, z=-923.94], np['Painting'/29, l='MpServer', x=640.06, y=51.50, z=-914.00], np['Painting'/26, l='MpServer', x=646.94, y=51.00, z=-922.00], np['Painting'/27, l='MpServer', x=644.06, y=51.00, z=-922.00]]
	Retry entities: 0 total; []
Stacktrace:
	at bdt.a(SourceFile:282)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.b(SourceFile:1881)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(SourceFile:535)
	at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)

-- System Details --
Details:
	Minecraft Version: 1.5.1
	Operating System: Windows 7 (amd64) version 6.1
	Java Version: 1.7.0_06, Oracle Corporation
	Java VM Version: Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM (mixed mode), Oracle Corporation
	Memory: 226594320 bytes (216 MB) / 615383040 bytes (586 MB) up to 954466304 bytes (910 MB)
	JVM Flags: 2 total; -Xms512m -Xmx1024m
	AABB Pool Size: 282 (15792 bytes; 0 MB) allocated, 4 (224 bytes; 0 MB) used
	Suspicious classes: No suspicious classes found.
	IntCache: cache: 0, tcache: 0, allocated: 0, tallocated: 0
	LWJGL: 2.4.2
	OpenGL: GeForce GT 630M/PCIe/SSE2 GL version 4.2.0, NVIDIA Corporation
	Is Modded: Probably not. Jar signature remains and client brand is untouched.
	Type: Client (map_client.txt)
	Texture Pack: Default
	Profiler Position: N/A (disabled)
	Vec3 Pool Size: 230 (12880 bytes; 0 MB) allocated, 19 (1064 bytes; 0 MB) used

Aligot Mash 2013-04-07T14:10:12Z

File uploaded. Chestplate ID is (#0315) in screenshot

Mustek 2013-04-07T14:10:58Z

I thought you said the chestplate was slightly damaged? Or does it do the same thing here as well?

Aligot Mash 2013-04-07T14:11:47Z

Regardless of whether the chestplate is slightly damaged or not, the enchantment does not work.

Mustek 2013-04-07T14:15:44Z

Going to reopen this, but I'm unable to reproduce it.

Mustek 2013-04-07T14:19:41Z

And resolving. Let me try to explain this:
You are trying to enchant with an enchanted written book.
In other words, that book is enchanted with Torns 2.

Enchanted books that can enchant other items have a yellow text. Enchanted items themselves, such as that book, have a blue text.
Thanks to Tails for noticing that 🙂

Aligot Mash 2013-04-07T14:20:20Z

What if the chestplate was generated before 1.4.6 or 1.4.7 when Thorns was introduced, making it incompatible with Thorns? Is there a duplicate for this theory? So now it becomes "Chestplates from old versions are incompatible with new enchantment(s)"

Aligot Mash 2013-04-07T14:22:06Z

Oh wait. The Thorns was on the book. Argh, why didn't I notice >.< Thanks anyway!

Anon Ymus 2013-04-07T15:35:42Z

As a side note, you may want to consider updating your Java. The current version is 1.7.0_17.