The bug
If you create a custom challenge advancement with no xp reward, the xp ding is apparently a part of the other sound that plays when you get it.
Comments 11
@BoyrexMacaraya No, it's not due to game mode. I specifically made sure that there was no xp reward in this custom advancement. You have to specify that you want an xp reward in the advancement .json file for there to be one. This isn't invalid.
This is not invalid @unknown.
Isn't the xp dings effect included in the sound effect for reaching the challenge? If so, I would presume it is intended.
@qwerty23495, it is indeed included within the sound effect itself. But I don't think that this issue is Works As Intended. I see absolutely no reason why the developers would put an xp ding sound in the sound effect if all of their default challenges, upon completion, give xp rewards, and therefore already make that sound. Do you see a reason?
Can confirm that this is an issue in 20w49a. I used the follow to reproduce:
/advancement grant @s only minecraft:adventure/adventuring_timeNote: Make sure you don't already have this advancement unlocked otherwise you won't be able to reproduce this.
Invalid! I assume you are on Creative mode.
It rewards you experience which plays the
dingsound, and you can still hear it even on Creative mode. This is not a bug.