After visiting a few villages, which spawned with some cats, I tamed a horse. This made me get the challenge "A Complete Dialogue", although the cats werent tamed by me.
Related issues
duplicates
Comments
migrated
MC-141076
Getting a wrong Advancement
Resolved
Duplicate
0
migrated
migrated
(Unassigned)
Unconfirmed
Minecraft 18w50a
Retrieved
To note: I tested this out, and you do not have to have encountered cats at all. Simply tame a horse and the "A Complete Catalogue" appears