The bug
Sometimes, the Survival inventory in Creative is not cleared when shift-clicking onto the X button.
To reproduce
Load a full 9-slot quick-toolbar with X+[number]
Pick-block a block or item (so that one item from the quickbar gets moved to the inventory)
Loading that or any other quickbar with X+[number]
Open the Survival Inventory inside the Creative Inventory
Shift-click the red "Destroy Item" button
→ ❌ The items moved into the inventory out of the quickbar by pick-blocking have not been deleted
Videos
[media]Related issues
is duplicated by
MC-156883
Shift-clicking the X in the Survival inventory in Creative mode does not destroy all of the items.
MC-174436
Some items cannot be cleared from inventory after shift-clicking on the "Destroy Items" button in creative mode
MC-182082
Creative inventory clear function not working correctly
MC-184258
"Delete All" button in Creative menu works inconsistently when pickblocking and swithing hotbars.
MC-190563
Creative inventory not fully clearing when shift-clicking the "destroy item" icon.
MC-250360
Elytra flight sometimes impossible after clearing inventory in Creative.
relates to
Attachments
Comments
migrated
SLScoolUser
I can confirm this also works in 1.14.4.
Based on the video you linked and my own experimentation, here's a procedure to replicate the bug:
Fill the hotbar as much as desired (can be left empty, but filling it with as many as 9 items makes step 2 quicker).
Pick-block anything from the world that is not already in your toolbar. Continue doing this until there is at least 10 different items in your inventory (i.e. a full hotbar, and at least 1 item not in your hotbar).
Load any toolbar.
Open to the "Survival Inventory" tab.
Shift-click the "Destroy Item" button.
And, like you said, any blocks which had been pick-blocked will not be deleted.
Some various, potentially helpful notes:
Loading a toolbar before doing the pick-blocking is not necessary, but it definitely makes the bug reproduction process faster.
For step 3, you can use any toolbar.
You can repeat steps 1, 2, and 3 as many times as you want, in any order (so long as the minimal requirements for the bug are met).
SLScoolUser
After some further experimentation, I found that the items are not getting deleted because they are ghost items (for some reason–which is why this bug report exists). /data get entity @p Inventory shows that the item is not saved in your inventory, reloading the world causes it to disappear, grabbing the item in survival mode causes it to disappear, etc.
SoloAlguien
Still in 20w12a
SoloAlguien
Still in 20w13b
SoloAlguien
Affects 20w14a
SoloAlguien
Affects 20w19a
SoloAlguien
Affects 20w20a
SoloAlguien
Affects 20w22a
SoloAlguien
Affects 1.16 Pre-release 2
SoloAlguien
Affects 1.16 Pre-release 3
SoloAlguien
Affects 1.16 Pre-release 4
SoloAlguien
Affects 1.16 Pre-release 5
Ray
in 1.16RC1
SoloAlguien
Affects 1.16.1
SoloAlguien
Affects 20w27a
SoloAlguien
Affects 20w28a
j_p_smith
Related to MC-86455.
pulpetti
In 20w29a
SoloAlguien
In 20w30a
migrated
Affects 20w46a
SoloAlguien
In 1.16.4
In 20w51a
SoloAlguien
In 21w03a
SoloAlguien
In 21w10a
SoloAlguien
In 21w11a
SoloAlguien
In 21w13a
SoloAlguien
In 21w14a
SoloAlguien
In 21w16a
SoloAlguien
In 21w17a
SoloAlguien
Can confirm in 21w18a.
SoloAlguien
Can confirm in 21w19a.
SoloAlguien
Can confirm in 21w20a.
SoloAlguien
Can confirm in 1.17 Pre-release 1.
SoloAlguien
Can confirm in 1.17 Pre-release 2.
SoloAlguien
Can confirm in 1.17 Pre-release 3.
SoloAlguien
Can confirm in 1.17 and 1.17.1 Pre-release 1.
SPGoding
Giving ownership of this ticket to @unknown.
migrated
Still a bug in 1.19.2, haven't checked in later versions
SoloAlguien
Fixed in 24w38a.