[MC-173756] Ice Bucket Challenge advancement can be obtained by collecting obsidian from bartering

Potentially not a bug, but it is possible to obtain the Ice Bucket Challenge advancement when getting obsidian from a piglin trade.

Linked issues

relates to 1

MC-178726 The advancement description of "Uneasy Alliance" states that ghasts have to be brought from the nether, but can be obtained from killing a ghast spawned in the overworld Reopened

Comments 5

PancakeIdentity 2020-03-11T22:43:49Z

The advancement uses the "inventory_changed" trigger and merely checks if the players has obsidian in their inventory. It was also obtainable through obsidian found in loot chests. Either the description should be changed or the trigger should be changed.

bluecrab2 2020-05-13T16:12:56Z

This still occurs in 20w20a - not fixed. Also might be WAI

Loek van Vucht 2020-05-13T16:20:28Z

The advancement is still granted to the player just by having obsidian in their inventory.

PancakeIdentity 2020-05-13T17:28:31Z

It's now WAI - this was "fixed" by changing the description to make this make sense. "Form and mine a block of obsidian" -> "Obtain a block of obsidian"

Loek van Vucht 2020-05-13T17:43:19Z

Makes sense. Thanks.