mojira.dev
MC-193907

Villager trade price increase without apparent reason

NOT A DUPLICATE

I had an amazing villager, a cured one. He traded 1 emerald (and a book) for a sharpness V book. 

He suddenly increased his trade price to 2 emeralds, but I can't find any reason why. I didn't hit or kill any villagers near him or anything of the sort. Nor did I heavily affect the supply/demand system, as I only bought the book twice. I've bought more mending books for 1 emerald and that price is still the same...

This happened again with a depth strider III villager (also 1 emerald). Except in this case, he increased it from 1 to 2 and, less than a minute or two later, to 3. 

I find this very weird... I have mending, fortune III and unbreaking III villagers who haven't changed their prices at all, even though they have been in the world for a longer time and I have traded with the first and last one more.

The reason I believe this is not a duplicate is because the previous ones were all dismissed by saying "You must've hurt a villager", "You probably bought him out", "You waited too long, the effect faded" (I don't think the major positive effect from cured villagers fades...), etc. I did nothing of the sort. (Didn't buy more than twice).

Thank you for reading through my issue 🙂

Linked issues

Comments 6

@SlicedBlock

(i)The reason I believe this is not a duplicate is because the previous ones were all dismissed by saying "You must've hurt a villager", "You probably bought him out", "You waited too long, the effect faded" (I don't think the major positive effect from cured villagers fades...), etc. I did nothing of the sort. (Didn't buy more than twice).:info:

Yeah, same thing happening to me with trading paper for emeralds. It went from 1 to 2, 2  to 3, and now 3 to 4.

...and it's only happening with some of them... I believe it could be an issue with pre-Village & Pillage villagers, because I have more of those villagers instead of regular villagers. Or it may affect villagers before the 1.16 update, not sure. I have one new villager, 3 are from 1.14.1 and the rest are older.

I just noticed that I'm in the Java bug report section. Something similar is happening on Bedrock Edition

Villagers will increase their prices temporarily if you use a trade too often in a short amount of time. Supply and demand.

Jellis Groen

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

(Unassigned)

1.16.1

Retrieved