[MC-222040] Can't get Suspicious stew from Moosrooms with Bowl in left hand and flower in main hand

I'm not sure if this is intented to work as such but in the past you could continously get Suspecious Stews from brown Mooshrooms by having Bowls in the left hand and Flowers in the main hand and keep holding both left and right mouse buttons.

Now this does not work, the game gives only the flower to the Mooshrom and the Bowl in the left hand does not "milk" it afterwards, forcing you to keep switching between slots in order to get it.

Having only Bowl in the left hand works though (for getting Mushroom Stew), just not with a combination with flowers. Is this a bug?

How to test it:

1) Get a brown Mooshroom

2) Get Bowls in the left hand, and any flower in the main hand.

3) Keep holding both mouse buttons while facing the Mooshroom.

Linked issues

duplicates 1

MC-219385 Attempting to feed brown mooshrooms with flowers that have already been fed plays the hand animation and produces particles Open

Comments 3

user-f2760 2021-04-02T22:41:00Z

AFAIK this is intended, the offhand is only used if the mainhand fails.

ATEMVEGETA 2021-04-02T23:10:19Z

But doesn't the main hand "fail" to give another flower?

bugsbugsbugs 2021-04-03T06:46:45Z

Yes, the mainhand is supposed to fail here. However because of MC-219385 it plays a hand animation and you try to feed it again now, preventing you from using the item in your offhand.
This used to be possible in 1.15.2, however the fix MC-178618, which causes MC-219385 prevents you from doing this, so this is a duplicate of/related to MC-219385.