mojira.dev
MC-2324

Player trapped/can't get out of flowing water

When I stand on a solid block that has a water source block on top of it (=feet level) and a sign on top of the water source block (=eyes' level), I cannot always climb up on top of a block that has (or not) another water source block on top of it. It is difficult to describe it in one sentence so I uploaded a video on Youtube: http://youtu.be/NI98uWkYm1o and I uploaded here the two test worlds. Better description below.

I notice that it occurs differently in each of the four quadrants of the world but it is identical at different spots in the same quadrant.

Case 1, the player tries to escape from water to air/air (feet / eyes level):
If the player is in the first quadrant of the map (x>0 and z>0) direction doesn't matter, he can exit to all 4 cardinal directions.
If the player is in the second quadrant of the map (x>0 and z<0) it is impossible to exit to the south side.
If the player is in the third quadrant of the map (x<0 and z<0) it is impossible to exit to the south and east side.
If the player is in the forth quadrant of the map (x<0 and z>0) it is impossible to exit to the east side.

Case 2, the player tries to exit from water / air to water source block / air (feet / eyes level):
If the player is in the first quadrant of the map (x>0 and z>0) it is impossible to exit to the south and east side.
If the player is in the second quadrant of the map (x>0 and z<0) it is impossible to exit to the south north and east side.
If the player is in the third quadrant of the map (x<0 and z<0) it is impossible to exit to all four sides.
If the player is in the forth quadrant of the map (x<0 and z>0) it is impossible to exit to the south west and east side.

(There is a symmetry of behavior between the second and the forth quadrant.)

So this bug renders mob spawner farms impossible to work most of the time.

EDIT:
About the attached photos:
Lime wool means that the player can escape to that block.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 19

EDIT: This comment is about the new attachments:
Lime wool means that the player can escape to that block.
New world save uploaded.

Can a mod please mark this as confirmed. This report is exactly for the same bug as in MC-3510 just with extended description of the circumstances under which it occurs. MC-3510 was reported after this one here and instead of closing it as duplicate it gets confirmed while this one remains unconfirmed.

EDIT: Thank you very much!

Yessir!

This has been around forever, and has annoyed the hell out of me! lol

Still goes on in 1.5.

9 more comments
[Mod] redstonehelper

We can't put older versions as fix version, sorry. Please do create a new ticket for your newly discovered/rediscovered flaws in 1.8.9 and make sure they also affect 16w02a.

Just tested it - the behavior I described is fixed in 16w02a (so I'm not going to bother creating another ticket since it's already fixed).

I am encountering this problem in the latest 1.13 pre-release (6).

 

cant hop up onto a block if in water of level 3 or lower.

This bug specifically was a directional one for negative coordinates. I think the issue you're having is MC-132632.

Marios

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

block, climb, escape, exit, jump, source, swim, trapped, water

Minecraft 1.4.2, Minecraft 1.4.4, Minecraft 1.4.5, Minecraft 1.4.6, Minecraft 1.4.7, ..., Minecraft 14w03b, Minecraft 1.7.10, Minecraft 14w30c, Minecraft 14w31a, Minecraft 1.8.1-pre3

Minecraft 1.8.9, Minecraft 16w02a

Retrieved