mojira.dev
MC-240470

Static noise at the end of block placement sound effects

The generic sound effects for placing various blocks seem to have static after playback.

If you listen carefully and place a block with the stone sound effect (e.g: cobblestone) you can hear static in the quiet portion of the effect.

To illustrate:

you hear: *plop -> little bit of silence -> static"

Replacing the sound effects with a resource pack does not have the same issue so a playback issue can probably be ruled out, this leads me to believe it's a source issue with the .ogg files.

Figured it could be my setup so i tested it on both Linux and Windows, both openjdk 17.

Also tested it on an external dac (apple usb-c -> 3.5mm converter) and on my onboard audio, both have the same issue. To further rule out hardware failure i tested with multiple headphones (Audio technica ath m50x and an akg k371), on both i could hear the static.

This almost confirms to me that it's a source issue.

So far this issue is present on the following placement sounds:

  • Generic stone (cobble, granite, stone, etc)

  • Generic wood (planks, etc)

  • Generic dirt (dirt, etc)

 

It seems to be present on some generic breaking sounds aswell.

I think it might also be caused by sudden stop of playback, although i'd expect it to be present on more sound effects aswell.

Snapshot 21w43a has the same issue aswell.

It's also audible on the fandom wiki if you play the sound effect.

Tested on both java 16 and java 17, both have the issue.

Update 05/11/2021

 Video demonstrating the issue with debug screen as asked below:

https://youtu.be/SKb3aPB4wCc

Turn your volume up a bit, it's most audible when placing dirt.

Something i noticed whilst recording: the static seems to occur when the sounds counter decreases.

 

Comments 5

Please provide a video of this issue occurring whilst the F3 debug screen is enabled.

I've added the video to the report.

https://youtu.be/SKb3aPB4wCc

 

I can't here any static from you placing blocks down. You are most likely just hearing your own footsteps

I was able to hear it on the video he provided, make sure to listen carefully

Can you still reproduce this issue in 1.20.2? I was unable to notice static sounds when placing and breaking blocks myself.

David M

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

(Unassigned)

1.17.1, 21w43a, 21w44a

Retrieved