[MC-277142] Pale Oak Trees Can Generate With A Hole In Them That Traps The Creaking

Pale Oak trees have the possibility of generating with a 1x3 hole in the trunk, allowing the associated Creaking Heart to spawn The Creaking inside of the tree, trapping it instantly. Steps to reproduce: load up snapshot 24w40a, run the /locate command to navigate to the nearest Pale Garden, and there's a chance that one of the Pale Oak trees will have a trapped Creaking at night

Linked issues

duplicates 1

MC-277115 Creaking mob can spawn inside block Resolved

Attachments

Comments 4

[Mod] Jingy 2024-10-02T21:21:20Z

This appears to be MC-277115. Would you say that describes your issue?

egg_228 2024-10-02T21:43:55Z

Potentially related but not entirely: MC-277115 appears to be related to collision checks, the issue I've encounted is due to the generation of trees, possibly due to Pale Hanging Moss replacing Pale Oak logs - after more testing, trees can also spawn with 2x1 holes in them as well

Avoma 2024-10-09T11:02:33Z

I don't really see how this is different from MC-277115. If MC-277115 had been fixed, this issue wouldn't occur. Resolving as a duplicate of MC-277115.

egg_228 2024-10-09T14:23:27Z

MC-277115 has the Creaking spawning with its head/upper body inside of blocks.

The Pale Oak tree can generate with a hole in it that is the exact size and shape of the Creaking. When this happens, the Creaking can spawn trapped inside of the tree.

MC-277115 is related to this issue because Pale Oak trees can also generate with holes in them similar to the one pictured on that bug report's page, which also traps the Creaking because of that. Fixing MC-277115 wouldn't fix this issue, because the Pale Oak tree will still have the chance of generating with a hole in it that is the exact size and shape of the Creaking