Enabling the Exclusive Fullscreen option while the game is windowed and then entering non-exclusive fullscreen does not disable Exclusive Fullscreen. This means that the next time the game is launched, it opens in exclusive fullscreen despite having been in non-exclusive fullscreen previously.
To reproduce
Launch the game
Make the game windowed (Fullscreen: OFF) if it is not already
Set Exclusive Fullscreen to ON
Enter non-exclusive fullscreen (on Mac, click the green button at the top left of the window or press
ctrl + cmd + F)
❌ The Exclusive Fullscreen button still shows ON
Expected behavior
Exclusive Fullscreen would be set to OFF upon entering non-exclusive fullscreen.
Note
This issue seems most impactful on macOS due to Mac users having a stronger preference for non-exclusive fullscreen since it allows for switching apps with a three-finger trackpad swipe (and also due to MC-311647). As of writing this, the issue has not been confirmed on Windows or Linux.
Environment
MacOS 27.0 Golden Gate
Can confirm, but to ensure the issue is correctly understood by Mojang I must completely rewrite this report (edit: done).