The Bug:
/scoreboard players reset reports success for targets that have no score to reset.
The /tag remove and /scoreboard players enable commands only count the targets that were changed and fail when nothing was changed. However, the /scoreboard players reset command still succeeds and counts every target, even those that have no score to reset, therefore introducing an inconsistency.
Steps to Reproduce:
Create a scoreboard objective by using the command provided below.
/scoreboard objectives add test dummyWithout setting a score, reset your score by using the command provided below.
/scoreboard players reset @s testObserve if the "Reset [test] for <player>" message is shown in chat.
Observed Behavior:
The command succeeds and shows "Reset [test] for <player>" despite there being no score to reset.
Expected Behavior:
Resetting a score that doesn't exist would fail.