Villagers(Farmers) can't replant crops

Was this world created before 14w03x ? If so, are the villagers being tested from before then?

I understand your first question, David, to that one my answer is No. but the second 1 I don't understand what you mean.

Mathias - If the answer to the first is no, the second is not an issue. We've been testing both worlds freshly created with the new villagers, upgraded worlds with only old villagers, and upgraded worlds with newly bred villagers to replace the old ones. Just trying to narrow things down.

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version 14w11b or later? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases. - bot

14w19a - I'm having this problem. 4 Farmer Villagers in full and grown fields not farming and will not accept stacks of Seeds. Carrots, Potatoes. They just wander around like villagers of old.

I tried eggs and

/summon Villager ~ ~1 ~ {CanPickUpLoot:1, Profession:0, Career:1}

I tried PickUpLoot:0 for the heck of it too. No Joy. It doesn't seem that "Career:" does anything because no matter what I put, I got a Random Farmer type.

I hope that its ok to post the / command here. If not, please edit it out.

Still not working on 14w20b.

To help with troubleshooting, or maybe to provide a reason for my particular issue...

I play 2 identical worlds that I have played since I started playing @ 6 months ago. I copied my "Non-Snapshot" world to play the snapshots because I lost all of my items once by playing on the same copy.

The current world I am having problems with is a copied world from 1.7.9. The only thing I use on my "official version" world, other than Minecraft, is OptiFineHD.

Still not working on 14w20b

Thank you

I hope its ok that I'm consecutive posting... I figure the mod only gets notified with a new post, not an edit. Let me know if I'm mistaken.

Still bad in 14w21b

Thanks!

I figure the mod only gets notified with a new post, not an edit. Let me know if I'm mistaken.

In fact everyone watching this ticket (top right "Watchers") gets notified at any change (edit or new comment)

In an effort to do some basic troubleshooting, I copied my problem world and tested random snapshots all the way back to 14w03b. None of the farmers farmed. Even in snapshots that were working previously.

I then created an entirely new world and built a quick farm based on the farm in my problem world and the farmers farmed like they were supposed to.

Since the only thing I ever used on my problem world, as stated above, was OptfFneHD 1.7.9, I assume that OptiFine uses a variable or process that interrupts normal farming and this process stays resident after a copy even though OptiFine is no longer loaded.

If that assumption is correct, this issue should affect a fair amount of folks. If I'm totally off base, then I'm stumped.

Thank you

Edit: 14w25a - No Joy. A bit of weirdness, the new Model: always says "IDUNNONAME:X(" on everything I highlight.
Edit: 14w25b - No Joy.
Edit: After recovering from world corruption, 14w26c - No Joy.
Edit: 14w27b - Bunnies, but no farming.
Edit: 14w28b still not fixed
Edit 14w29b, No fix.
Edit 14w30b, No fix.

Since no one's mentioned it so far, if you have the gamerule "mobGriefing" set to false then villagers can't farm. However this would prevent them from breaking the crops too and people seem to be saying it's actually the replanting that they're not doing. Just figure maybe 1 or 2 people are actually here because of the gamerule not the bug. It's not set that way by default of course.

Nice thought. I did have mobGreifing False, but alas, after changing it to true and re-spawning a farmer, no joy.

I did however, create a new world with the same seed. I copied over most of my structures with MCEdit and the farmers started farming on the new world.

I can't believe this! My farmers on my new world have stopped farming completely. 14w30c. They were farming fine... Once again, this is a NEW world where they were farming just fine.

Please fix this.

Edit, I thought I set mobGriefing, but forgot that I removed that command block so I never messed with the setting. They just stopped on their own accord.

14w31a lazy farmers still aren't farming and don't pick up dropped carrots, potatos, etc...!
14w32d No Joy.

I've run into the same problem. I started half a dozen different worlds and searched for a village. The farming was working fine in the beginning (though on a side note, it wasn't just the farmers but every villager who harvested and replanted), but after a while, they stopped. They don't pick up items thrown at them anymore either. It doesn't matter whether it's an original villager, a grownup baby one or an egg-spawned one. In some worlds, I had mobGriefing switched off, in some I had left it on, no difference.
Checked with NTBExplorer, canPickUpLoot=1, and the inventories are nowhere near full.
Same issue from my first attempt (about 14w32a) to 1.8 release version.

I'm glad someone could finally verify this. That's exactly what happened to me.

As far as I can see, there are no attachments so far, could a mod comment as to whether a savegame-zip would help? Or we could try to work out some commonalities like OS, memory, mods (I'm just using vanilla without any mods whatsoever currently),....