mojira.dev
MC-53848

Lava not setting wood on fire

See attached screenshot. A flat surface of wood never catches fire from lava placed on top of it. I've left a world open like this for over an hour with nothing catching on fire.

I've confirmed that doFireTick is set to true. If I create a one block hole and put lava in the hole, the surrounding wood will quickly catch fire. If I put a block of wood at the same Y level as the lava, it will eventually catch fire, and then set the rest of the wood on fire.

Attachments

Comments 5

Confirmed for 14w18b. You need to break some blocks.

Still present in 14w33c.

Present in 1.8.

This is easy to verify by setting randomTickSpeed to something like 3000.

This is emergent behaviour due to the way that lava sets flammable blocks on fire.

There is a specific area of blocks above a lava source, namely the 3x3 directly above the lava block, and 5x5 on the next layer up: http://i.stack.imgur.com/1vNGB.png (Fire blocks have a similar area, but it is a different shape)

In technical terms, any air block in this area, which has a flammable block beside it, will be converted to a fire block when it receives a random tick (note that the flammable block does not have to be within this area).

Now, looking at your screenshot:

[media]

Comparing this to the valid set of flammable blocks, you will note that none of the wood blocks in your screenshot are next to a block that is valid to become fire. Also note that the top surface of the logs are covered by flowing lava, so they are not valid to become fire blocks.

I am not certain on the rules here, but I believe flowing lava will not set flammable blocks on fire, except for falling lava (created when flowing lava drops down one block - this is why breaking a wood block and letting the lava flow down will set the wood on fire).

In conclusion, I'm going to say that this behaviour, while counter-intuitive, is by design.

Lava is being more likely to set wood above it on fire even when they are separated. 

A wooden walkway in a cave was set on fire by a pool of lava below it, but separated by 8 blocks of air.  A mansion was set on fire, apparently by a pool of lava below it and separated by at least 5 blocks of stone,

Was the behavior of lava supposed to have been changed in the update?

Hayden Muhl

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Minecraft 1.7.9, Minecraft 14w17a

Retrieved