mojira.dev
MC-57580

Using silk-touch on huge mushrooms drops all-cap blocks instead of all-spore blocks

bug in the summary.

has data of 0, the current all-spore block. as there is also an all-cap block available right now (data:14), this is most likely a bug.

some suggestions:

there should probably also a way to get the all-spore one (as it drops right now). Maybe it should drop the all-cap one by default and then you can cook it to get the all-spore one. or maybe just the outermost cap blocks are all-cap and the inner ones all-spore.

the stems currently also drop the all-spore (currently cap) blocks, which seems a bit odd. you should probably make them drop an all-stem one. also the stem is the same texture for both types of huge mushroom, you could probably unify them to one block if you finally switch away from the id/metadata system, if you don't intend to give each mushroom stem its own texture.

also none of these blocks are available in the creative menu despite being (partially) available in survival.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 4

Confirmed, though may be an intended change. It does allow you to differentiate between the two, which previously appeared identical but did not stack (MC-13543).

I doubt it. There was an all-cap available the whole time already (metadata:14), so you would effectively just remove the corresponding all-spore (data:0) when you replace their texture with the all-cap one. Either way it would be a bug.

Most of the huge mushroom blocks are not intended to be acquired or placed by the player.

To clarify this a bit: data 0 is the all-spore now again ( at least for the red huge mushroom, didn't try the brown one ), but the huge mushroom structure drops the all-cap blocks now. So the old blocks stay the same, but are no longer obtainable. Better stock up on them if you play some kiddie server 😛

(tested in 14w28b)

Guybrush Threepwood

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Minecraft 14w25a

Retrieved