mojira.dev
MC-5898

Lamps, Signs Fence Gates, and sheep eating grass don't give block updates!

Previously, when a redstone lamp or fence gate was toggled it would cause a block update (i was attempting to use it to update a piston for redstone purposes), but in the latest snapshot it does not. Regardless of whether this is a "fix" or a bug, a vast proportion of redstone contraptions use this functionality and if it is removed then they will all be completely broken. It would be a shame if the "Redstone update" broke the vast majority of redstone made since 1.2.

Linked issues

MC-7688 Bug with BUD switches Resolved MC-8131 Jukeboxes don't trigger BUD switches. Resolved MC-8863 Pistons do not update Resolved MC-10800 Sheep don't cause block updates when eating grass. Resolved MC-11091 Cocoa beans dont update blocks when planted or grow, wheat doesn't update blocks during growth Resolved

Comments 17

Confirmed.

they need to add a bud block or keep this in game

and yes, I know it's allmost impossible to make a bud block

And no, they shouldn't add a block, as the BUD isn't only a switch. Heres a vid that explains the fully potential of BUDs and why they should stay(in their current form, not as an block): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYe_xe7SNKY

Dalton Richardson

Even if they did add an official BUD, this kind of (hopefully) bug would make them much harder to use. For people who actually mind the quasi-connectivity problems, these not causing updates makes them more difficult to deal with.

7 more comments

please fix this bug please!

I would like to add, that this is also the case for growth of crops.
For example wheat growing does not cause block updates as it should.

If a sheep eats a grass block and turns the block into dirt, the server doesn't fire a block update.
Please add the flag for block update to the responsible eating grass AI to fix this.
Thanks.

strage that sheep eating grass doesnt cause a block update but grass dying from having something on top of it does

if observers detect this, why don't pistons? 

Joe Gocher

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

block-update, fence_gate, grass_block, piston, redstone_lamp, sheep

Snapshot 13w01a, Snapshot 13w01b, Snapshot 13w02a, Minecraft 1.5, Snapshot 13w11a, ..., Snapshot 13w24a, Snapshot 13w24b, Snapshot 13w25a, Snapshot 13w25b, Snapshot 13w25c

Retrieved