CTRL + Pick Block not working correctly with Jukeboxes

When I take a jukebox with a record in it, and I use CTRL + Pick Block to get the NBT data, it shows it has the NBT data in my inventory but when I place it and right click, the record doesn't come out. If I break it it will come out, and I can put another record in, but when I break it after I put a new one in, the old one doesn't drop.