mojira.dev
MC-7222

1-9 keys, hoppers/droppers and shift-clicking ignore stacking restrictions

Using 1-9 keys, hoppers or droppers, and shift-clicking, stack height restrictions can be circumvented. This affects several slots:

Slot

Items

1-9 keys

Hoppers/Droppers

Shift-clicking

Beacon

Diamonds, Emeralds, Iron Ingots, Gold Ingots

Fixed in 15w44b

No

No

Furnace fuel slot

Buckets

Fixed in 15w44b

Fixed in 15w44b

No

Enchanting table

Any stackable item

Fixed in 15w44b

No

No

Armor head slot

Pumpkins, Skulls of any type

Fixed in 15w44b

No

Fixed

Brewing Stand

Glass bottles

Fixed in 15w44b

Not fixed

Not fixed

Each of these should only allow a single item.

Environment

Windows 7, 64 bit. Java 7

Linked issues

MC-11838 1-9 keys ignore stacking restrictions Resolved MC-15433 Hoppers and Beacons Resolved MC-76784 Pumpkins can be weared stacked by pressing numbers Resolved MC-78906 Brewing Stands have Shift place Resolved MC-92242 Pumpkins bug Resolved
MC-114462 Shift clicking ignores stacking restrictions if the same item is already in the slot Open MC-1973 Items placed into a beacon are lost upon reloading a world Resolved MC-2034 Brewing stands' input slots do not have normal stacking behavior Resolved MC-14549 Inconsistent behavior with shift-clicking items into single item slots Open MC-93164 Using a hotkey on items in inventory slots you can't insert items into (e.g. Crafting table output) only works if slot is empty Reopened

Comments 21

Can confirm, though even if pressing done only 1 item is consumed, so maybe it should rather be allowed to stack manually.

Good idea, never thought of it like that.

Letting them stack in the beacon would be a better fix than letting only one item fall in.

When a stack of items that are not diamond, emerald, iron ingot, or gold ingot are fed in to a beacon from a dropper or hopper then the item stack will diaper leaving only 1 item out of the full stack in its place.

You can also 1-9 click a stack into the beacon, so yeah letting the player normally stack the items in the beacon would be the best solution IMO.

11 more comments

Not fixed for brewing stands. Please reopen.

Reopened for 1.11

Glass bottles (empty) still stack using both hopper and shift-click

Glass bottles still stack in brewing stands as of 22w16a.

migrated

migrated

Confirmed

beacons, hopper

Snapshot 13w02b, Minecraft 1.5, Snapshot 13w11a, Snapshot 13w19a, Minecraft 1.7.4, , Minecraft 16w32a, Minecraft 16w32b, Minecraft 16w33a, Minecraft 16w35a, Minecraft 1.11

Minecraft 15w44b, Minecraft 16w50a

Retrieved