I would feed two turtles sea grass, and there would be the breeding Hearts and bumping into each other, but instead of laying eggs, one of the turtles would sit in a corner and do almost nothing, and the other would just behave as normal. You can’t feed the one sitting in a corner again, but the one just going on with their day could be fed.
Not sure where the delete button is, but an update, they apparently wanted to roam more. Sorry about that.