Todays log in has produce a massive drop in villager again. 6 have vanished with jobs. All of them were replacements for the last vanishing group of villagers.
You resolve nothing by closing these tickets and linking to the vast mess that is main thread for this.
The solutions you link to are not acceptable. This is your problem and saying it's because people are crossing borders and/or doing something to cause this is not a reason. This is a bug which needs fixing before you unleash more useless content for the masses. Stop offering realms without information that they are KNOWN to delete your villagers or mobs.
I want advice, not palming off.
They are not on chunk borders. I have not left my chunk for 2 days as I'm levelling out the whole area. I've not been in the nether, off exploring.
WHAT SHOULD I DO?
Today will be the day I cancel my subscription to Minecraft realms.
A VERY disappointing end to what myself and my daughter were looking forward to.
Related issues
Comments
[Mod] Umija5895M
[Mod] Umija5895M
After additional research and discussion with other mods, this report is being resolved as a duplicate of MCPE-21416. Mobs crossing chunk borders is not a requirement for that to be a separate issue.
In general, it does seem that the issue mainly occurs when an area is reloaded. This can happen when logging into the world, or if another player on the realm moves in or out of the area. All of these kinds of issues are tracked as MCPE-21416.
migrated
How long has this issue been a problem?.....Fix it.......My issue relates to the masses of other issues that sound similar or exactly the same. My problem is that you tell us to report our bugs then resolve it within a very very short time....It's not resolved in your links at all. Therefore you have not resolved my issue. Telling people its due to crossing chunks or borders then saving etc etc etc is not resolved that's just a cause. Sick of it. Work to rebuild after the 1st wave of villagers evaporate just to be faced with exactly the same again today. Due you realise how hard it is to farm all he stuff to get to the point of trading decent stuff? Just to be bugged out and have to start again. Minecraft realms is paid for for reasons of fun. Thats all...Its not if this happens.
Just to be clear. I see no resolve in any of your resolved cases. Just passing blame to players who do something to activate a bug of yours.
You may indeed have a different issue than what is generally tracked in MCPE-21416. However, there's really not enough information in your report to determine that for certain, nor to reproduce the specific issue you are having. In general, the Description should include a clear enough explanation of the conditions that someone else can reproduce the issue. This is best done by including Steps to Reproduce along with Observed and Expected behaviors (even if it's obvious), as described in Writing Helpful Bug Reports. In this case, screenshots showing the locations where the villagers are/were contained and that clearly show that that there are no chunk border crossings would help to demonstrate that this is not an issue with entities being lost at chunk borders.
Additionally, the bug tracker is primarily a reporting system, not a place to get help or advice, nor is it a discussion forum. For help, you might want to visit Community Support. To discuss bugs in Minecraft, you can visit the Mojira Discord community.
This ticket has been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response. It will automatically reopen when you add information.