mojira.dev
MCPE-153869

/kill @e kills players in Spectator mode

type in /gamemode 6 to enter spectator mode and type in /kill @e and you also die and that shouldn't happen

Linked issues

MCPE-156964 you can die with /kill @e in spectator mode Resolved MCPE-161111 Spectator Able to be /killed Resolved MCPE-162259 Spectator mode can die while doing a /kill Resolved MCPE-162560 /kill all entities command kills player in spectator mode. Resolved MCPE-163309 Spectator mode can get /kill Resolved

Comments 2

Probably because spectator mode is based off of survival because you can see the hunger and health bar in spectator in 1.18 because it happens in this video

We're marking this as 'Works as Intended'. /kill @e will kill spectators in Java Edition so we have made it work in the same way in Bedrock Edition.

We are discussing this inside Mojang and might change this decision later. In Bedrock edition, /kill @e ignores creative players and it would make sense for it to also ignore spectators, but this would mean introducing a parity break with Java Edition.

Albert Arlt

(Unassigned)

763092

Confirmed

Windows

Windows 11

1.19.10.23 Preview, 1.19.10.22 Preview, 1.19.0.21 Preview, 1.19.0

Retrieved