mojira.dev
MCPE-164869

[Experimental] Duplicate Recipes Being Skipped On Custom Tables

In 1.19.50 duplicate crafting recipes now throw content log errors and are skipped unless the recipe is crafted in a block with the tag 'crafting_table' or 'stonecutter'.

I have a table saw block that acts as a stonecutter for wood, this new update has ruined this block as every recipe has a 'table_saw' tag but despite using a crafting table interface, all recipes except one are skipped. 

Steps To Reproduce:

  • Create a custom crafting table that uses a custom tag

  • Add two recipes that can only be crafted in this block using the same ingredients but output different items.

  • Attempt to craft both items and observe only one recipe is present

  • Change the crafting tag from the custom tag to 'crafting_table'

  • Go to a crafting table and observe both recipes are now present

Expected Results:

  • The new system of skipping recipes only applies to furnace and potion recipes (as those would actually cause issues) and shaped recipes are allowed to have duplicate recipes as the crafting book allows the player to select which recipe they'd like to craft.

Observed Results:

  • Custom crafting tables that don't use the 'crafting_table' tag cannot accept duplicate recipes despite being a crafting table.

Attachments

Comments 5

Is this still an issue in the newest version?

The recipes that failed were shapeless recipes, I recently changed them to be shaped which fixed them being skipped but there is still hundreds of warnings appearing when loading a world which could potentially obstruct other actual issues. I'm not sure why this 'fix' was even needed in the first place. At least give us the option to disable warnings like this.

I can confirm this bug is still happening with custom crafting tables in 1.20.15, but as you can see the recipes work perfectly fine.

[media][media]

I still experience the issue in v1.20.51.01.

Resolving temporarily as Awaiting Response. Could you add an example add-on to your report?
This ticket will reopen automatically when you reply.

Gruntastic

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Multiple

add-on, crafting, custom-blocks, recipe, recipe-book, tags

1.19.50, 1.19.63

Retrieved