mojira.dev
MCPE-168717

Stone Block Slab Recipe Duplication Content Log Errors and they are NOT Dupes

Note: This should be in MCPE - do not know how to move it.

Brief Summary:

I have 1176 custom slab combos and their corresponding shapeless recipes.  9 of them are reporting as duplicates.  They all happen to be of the minecraft:stone_block_slab2 or 3 or 4 variety.  I have isolated all of the issues and included them in a mcAddon file attached. 

All files are named with the formula  blocktype1_dataID1_and_blocktype2_dataID2. 

For the recipes, inside ingredients match the filename.  Impossible for them to be dups.

Steps to Reproduce:
Using one of the errors as an example:

  1. Make one shapeless recipe file with  {"item":"minecraft:stone_block_slab2","data":3},{"item":"minecraft:stone_block_slab4","data":0}
    2.Make another with 
    {"item":"minecraft:stone_block_slab2","data":0}
    ,{"item":"minecraft:stone_block_slab4","data":3}

Observed Results:
Content Log Errors - Attached

From above example:

[Recipes][warning]-recipes/dupes/stone_block_slab2_3_and_stone_block_slab4_0.recipe.json | scr:stone_block_slab2_3_and_stone_block_slab4_0 | Recipe "scr:stone_block_slab2_3_and_stone_block_slab4_0" has the same ingredients as slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_0_and_stone_block_slab4_3's recipe but outputs slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_3_and_stone_block_slab4_0 instead. Adding duplicate crafting_table recipe.

Expected Results:
no recipe duplication errors because they are not the same.

Attached:

1. addon with just the recipes/blocks in question

2. content log

Attachments

Comments 1

More Info

I grouped together the 9 sets of dupes from the lang file (because it has a block description)

I notice the 1st 3 have a pattern with numbers switching, but sadly, on 3 were predictable.

 
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_0_and_stone_block_slab4_3.name=Red Sandstone & Cut Sandstone Slab Combo   ##
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_3_and_stone_block_slab4_0.name=Dark Prismarine & Mossy Stone Brick Slab Combo ##

tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_0_and_stone_block_slab3_4.name=Red Sandstone & Diorite Slab Combo ##
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_4_and_stone_block_slab3_0.name=Prismarine Bricks & End Stone Bricks Slab Combo    ##

tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_0_and_stone_block_slab3_6.name=Red Sandstone & Granite Slab Combo ##
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_6_and_stone_block_slab3_0.name=Smooth Sandstone & End Stone Bricks Slab Combo ##

tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_4_and_stone_block_slab3_6.name=Prismarine Bricks & Granite Slab Combo ##
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_6_and_stone_block_slab3_4.name=Smooth Sandstone & Diorite Slab Combo  ##

tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_3_and_stone_block_slab3_7.name=Dark Prismarine & Polished Granite Slab Combo  ##
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_7_and_stone_block_slab3_3.name=Red Nether Bricks & Andesite Slab Combo    ##

tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab3_0_and_stone_block_slab3_2.name=End Stone Bricks & Polished Andesite Slab Combo    ##
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_0_and_stone_block_slab4_2.name=Red Sandstone & Stone Slab Combo   ##

tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab3_2_and_stone_block_slab3_4.name=Polished Andesite & Diorite Slab Combo ##
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_4_and_stone_block_slab4_2.name=Prismarine Bricks & Stone Slab Combo   ##

tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab3_2_and_stone_block_slab3_6.name=Polished Andesite & Granite Slab Combo ##
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_6_and_stone_block_slab4_2.name=Smooth Sandstone & Stone Slab Combo    ##

tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab2_7_and_stone_block_slab4_3.name=Red Nether Bricks & Cut Sandstone Slab Combo   ##
tile.slab_combo:stone_block_slab3_3_and_stone_block_slab3_7.name=Andesite & Polished Granite Slab Combo ##

DrinkWater623

(Unassigned)

998789

Confirmed

Windows

1.19.71

1.20.0.21 Preview, 1.20.0

Retrieved