mojira.dev
MCPE-241202

The loot table in 'bastion_generic' has a different number of rolls

Steps to Repro:

Open the two file paths:
Java: <version>.jar/data/minecraft/loot_table/chests/bastion_other.json

scroll all the way down to cooked_porkchop

Bedrock: C:/XboxGames/Minecraft for Windows/Content/data/behavior_packs/vanilla_1.20.0/loot_tables/chests/bastion_other.json

scroll all the way down to gilded_blackstone

You have to scroll to different places because, in Java, the rolls are listed below the pool entries, whereas in Bedrock they appear at the top.

Observed Results:

The pool containing obsidian, iron nuggets, cooked porkchop, etc., has a minimum of 3 and a maximum of 4 rolls in the Java Edition.

In the Bedrock Edition, it has a minimum of 3 and a maximum of 5 rolls, which results in a completely different probability.

Expected Results:
The pool has the same maximum number of rolls in both the Java Edition and the Bedrock Edition.

Attachments

Comments 1

bedrock loot table.png
java loot table.png

Here are two screenshots as attachments. I wasn't able to attach them when I created the report.

Kingcat

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Multiple

loot-table, vanilla-parity

26.50.24 Preview, 26.50.22 Preview, 26.33 Hotfix, 26.40

Retrieved