[MCPE-79380] Hand and some items still bob when View Bobbing is disabled

Summary:
The player's hand, bow, crossbow, trident, and shield in first-person view still bob when walking/running with View Bobbing disabled.

Steps to Reproduce:

Load a world
Disable View Bobbing
Start walking/running while holding nothing

Observed Results:
The player's hand still bobs.

Expected Results:
The player's hand should not bob.

Linked issues

is duplicated by 53

BDS-6258 View bobbing still works even if its disabled Resolved

BDS-8819 When i turn off my view bobbing my hand still moves when i walk Resolved

BDS-12638 View bobbing issue Resolved

MCPE-79573 "View bodding" movement appears with the setting turned off Resolved

MCPE-79835 When View Bobbing is off, your arm moves when empty Resolved

48 more links

relates to 2

MCPE-116678 The food eating animation position is offset Resolved

MCPE-117724 Wiggling your arm while swimming (first person) when View Bobbing is disabled Resolved

Attachments

Minecraft 2021-03-10 07-31-21_Trim.mp4

Minecraft 2021-03-10 07-31-21_Trim (2).mp4

Minecraft 2021-03-10 07-31-21_Trim (3).mp4

Minecraft 2021-03-10 07-31-21_Trim (4).mp4

Minecraft 2021-03-10 07-31-21_Trim (5).mp4

No Hand Bobbing.mcpack

Screenrecording_20200521_041508.mp4

Comments 20

Jason 2020-05-22T14:52:37Z

It appears this may affect only Android devices. Turning view bobbing off on Windows 10 doesn't cause this issue.

navynexus 2020-05-24T23:23:45Z

This issue occurs to me on Windows 10

CJ31926 2020-06-23T19:27:34Z

Happens for me on xbox one aswell

Sarah Washington 2020-06-24T00:19:57Z

This effects me on iOS as well

Jesse Kohn 2020-07-04T07:33:36Z

This happens on Switch as well, so I can confirm this happens on all bedrock platforms.

10 more comments

stonehands 2020-08-14T21:01:11Z

Still an issue in 1.16.2. If you hold a map in your offhand (or in your primary hand with a shield in the offhand) the map doesn't bob, but the hand underneath does.

Ehrenburg 2020-09-11T00:42:33Z

This problem seems to be caused by a wrong placed "!" in the "player.animation_controllers.json" file.
Removing the "!" on "first_person_walk" : "!variable.bob_animation" to "first_person_walk" : "variable.bob_animation" solves this problem.
Then the bobbing toggle works again normally.

Skaijie 2020-09-27T03:27:15Z

Since no one has done it, based on @unknown's comment I've added an mcpack that fixes the issue

Thong Tran 2020-09-28T06:46:57Z

Seem like everyone above have a way to fix this, but does your hand move at the opposite direction as your screen rotate ? I mean look at some video on Java Edition, or turn on view bobbing and get on a horse you’ll see, it make sense cause that’s not count as bobbing, it’s something else, i’m just doesn’t like how your hand just standing still all the time especially with my iPad where everything just stuck out of the screen and never visible at all, i could turn on view bobbing but i just don’t like it, Minecraft Bedrock always have these weird things that I don’t even understand lol, and is there anyone report the hand actually smaller than usual, is that something intentional or just some random bug like this one ?

GinePik 2020-10-01T13:50:39Z

Affects 1.16.100.58 Beta.

Natthan 2020-10-17T00:17:39Z

Affects 1.16.100.60

ambient 2020-10-24T17:56:11Z

another fix for this is to set the positioning for left and right arm to 0.0 for all axes in the first person walking animation. Both the animation controller method and this work, but the former is more simplistic.

"animation.player.first_person.walk" : {
            "loop" : true,
            "bones" : {
                "leftarm" : {
                    "position" : [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ]
                },
                "rightarm" : {
                    "position" : [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ]
                }
            }
        }

kmb600 2020-10-29T18:34:34Z

affects 1.16.200.52

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay) 2021-02-12T14:36:00Z

Reopening as this appears to be a regression in 1.16.210.59 beta.

silentwisperer 2021-02-15T17:24:04Z

can confirm, happens in the .59 beta 👍

xXGlitchSlayerXx 2021-03-10T14:03:06Z

This issue has made it into the 1.16.210 release.

ajarmand57 2021-03-11T05:10:48Z

I also confirm that this bug is present in 1.16.210 release on IOS mobile. The main problem is that offhand items move around even when view bobbing is turned off. Items in the main hand is not affected though. Very annoying.

silentwisperer 2021-03-28T21:50:36Z

this is still active in the 1.16.230.50 beta

lillybeacon 2021-04-03T05:06:56Z

For some reason, the view bobbing changes got reverted in the 1.16.230 beta, based on the changes inside the .json files, hopefully, it should be acknowledged pretty soon.

[Mod] EVGENSYPERPRO 2021-04-06T18:43:57Z

Version 1.16.220 is not affected.
Latest beta version (1.16.230.52) is affected.