mojira.dev
MC-103058

Non-Ops Can't Run Commands by Right-clicking Signs in Spawn Protected Chunks

Players can not right-click signs at spawn to run any commands, even commands like /trigger, which they would normally have access to.

I'm not convinced this is a bug, perhaps just an over-looked feature during development, but I was told when making a suggestion on the /r/MinecraftSuggestions subreddit to report this as a bug instead, so I'm putting it here to hopefully give this problem some attention.

Sorry if this has already been posted. I searched but couldn't find anything that seemed like the same thing.

Linked issues

Comments 8

I believe that sign clicking has been removed so that only opped players can run them. This is to protect servers, I think.

I thought about that, but I couldn't come up with any conceivable reason that would be the case. And even if it was, why wouldn't they be able to run commands that non-ops can normally run, like /trigger, /me, or /say?

I heard that now non-opped players are not able to execute all types of commands from signs. But you said that it's only in Spawn Protected Chunks right? Does it work anywhere else?

@@unknown It works anywhere else and without requiring OP status outside spawn-protection.

No, non-opped players definitely can run all commands through the signs (not just ones they could use in the command line) outside of spawn chunks. For example, I once built a store that used these signs to purchase, (the store had to be outside of spawn chunks) and the sign itself used a /setblock command, which ran a line of other command blocks.

Edit: this comment was directed to Tan Chin Cheern. I agree with Skylinerw. I also just tested this in 1.9.4 by deoping myself, leaving spawn, running a command through a sign. I haven't heard anything about this, so I doubt it's been fixed in any recent update.

I don't really know much about this, so I'm leaving it up to the mods to decide on this issue.

As that would be on a server you should talk the server owner/admin.

@Henry Walker I am the server owner/admin. This is a problem with the game itself, not my sever.

Keith

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Minecraft 1.9.4

Retrieved