The player hurts sound plays on top of the shield blocking and shield disabled sounds for the attacker, which is inconsistent with how the sounds play for the defender (there is no player hurts sound for the defender, which is expected as no damage is being done).
The following bug regarding the shield block and shield stun sounds not playing for attackers was fixed in 25w05a:
Attacking another player that is blocking with a shield in multiplayer plays the player hurt sound for the attacker, rather than playing the shield blocking sound. Additionally, stunning another player's shield using an axe also plays the player hurt sound for the attacker, rather than playing the shield stun sound.
The former issue makes shield PvP have poor audio queues, as playing the player hurt sound is misleading as no damage was done. The latter is extremely misleading as it completely fails to inform the attacker that they successfully stunned a shield.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 7
MC-112835
Shield block hit sound is only heard by the person blocking
Resolved
MC-128656
Inaccurate sound for hitting a player using a shield to block
Resolved
MC-154353
Shield-Sound Bug
Resolved
MC-188643
Shield Hit Sounds
Resolved
MC-200744
Incorrect sounds being played when fighting against a shield user in multiplayer
Resolved
relates to 1
Attachments
Comments 19
I'd like to request ownership of this ticket since the current reporter has been inactive for just under a year. I'm willing to continue to provide all of the necessary information and will keep this ticket updated accordingly.
Can confirm in 23w51a/23w51b, please add to the report that this also affects the shield stun sounds, not just the shield blocking sounds.
Can confirm in 24w06a, would like to request ownership of this report as the reportee has not elaborated on the description
Partially fixed in 25w04a. Created new report for the new behavior: MC-279713.
Also in 16w39c