mojira.dev
MC-107760

Observer activating in odd circumstances

When redstone (that is adjacent to the block the observer checks for updates) is updated the observer activates.
Note: it doesn't activate when the redstone is placed only when it is broken, powered, or the direction is changed in some way

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 7

Observers activate on a block update. The redstone dust in this case updates any block with a Manhatten distance (search it up, if you're confused) of 2

Duplicated by MC-108713. Affects 16w41a.

@G4me: there's a little more to that story: if you place redstone dust in front of the observer then it triggers due to the block update. If you then place another redstone dust in front it triggers again. Expected behavior because the initial redstone dust updated (changed from a round to a line). But if you then place a third redstone dust in front the observer triggers yet again. That shouldn't be happening because the block directly in front didn't update. However, the 2nd block did. So there's more to this than merely updating the block directly in front.

@ShelLuser To my knowledge, the block updates run from one side of the redstone wire to the other. So you are wrong. This isn't a bug. Only because it isn't visual, it doesn't mean nothing's happened

@Orell If we follow your reasoning then shouldn't the observer keep responding as long as you place redstone dust in a single connected line? Thing is: it doesn't, if you place the 3rd dust it'll respond (this triggers the "lower" or middle dust in the OP's picture) but if you then place a fourth then nothing happens anymore.

Seems to be fixed in 16w44a (see MC-109571)

Landon D.

Jens Bergensten

Confirmed

observer, redstone

Minecraft 16w39a, Minecraft 16w39b, Minecraft 16w40a, Minecraft 16w41a, Minecraft 16w42a, Minecraft 16w43a

Minecraft 16w44a

Retrieved