The bug
Based on the fix for MC-107550 items can now be in multiple creative inventory tabs. Because of this, I would expect Unbreaking and Mending to be in the Combat tab as well.
Comments 5
The above list is more a change suggestion then the bug that got fixed.
The bug that got fixed was about mending/unbreaking books only appearing in tools when they can be applied to the items from combat too, which can be considered a bug.
The list is a suggestion of changing where blocks/items are listed correct, but should be changed according to @unknown as they make less sense. That is a feature suggestion. As they are listed correctly and don't cause confusion (unlike the enchanted books).
@unknown Thanks
@unknown Suggest it on reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/
@FVbico
You could compare these two:
Enchantment 1 and 2 can be applied to items in tab A, but also items in tab B.
Brewing Ingredient 3 and 4 can be applied to items in tab C, but also applied to items in tab D
One could think/get confused by the placement of the enchanted books and think these enchantments only work for A, but also work for B.
On the other hand one could think/get confused by the placement of a food candidate in the brewing section or a brewing candidate in the materials section.
Ok, I get that the entries towards the bottom of the table become less applicable to above strategy, but may considering consistency be a good recommendation.
But for simplicity sake: https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/comments/5bw3d6/inconsistency_with_items_in_creative_tabs/
Well this seemed unusual to have items appear in multiple tabs, but at the very least make it consistent:
A list with highly recommended Tab changes/additions:
Affected Item
➕ Add to Creative Tab
➖ Remove from Creative Tab
❓ Reason
Spider Eye
Brewing
-
Mostly used for brewing
Pufferfish
Brewing
-
Mostly used for brewing
Nether Wart
Brewing
-
Mostly used for brewing
Chorus Fruit
Food
-
Can be eaten
Golden Carrot
Food
-
Can be eaten
Cauldron
Decorative Blocks
-
Utility block like furnace
Brewing Stand
Decorative Blocks
-
Utility block like furnace
Fireworks Star
-
Miscellaneous
useless item (if you want to hint new players that this item exists, add a template firework?)
Slimeball
Materials
Miscellaneous
Used in multiple crafting recipes
Book
Materials
Miscellaneous
Used in multiple crafting recipes
Paper
Materials
Miscellaneous
Used in multiple crafting recipes
Bone
Materials
Miscellaneous
Used in crafting recipe
Snowball
Materials
Miscellaneous
Used in crafting recipe
Ender Pearl
Materials
Miscellaneous
Used in crafting recipe
Ender Eye
Materials
Miscellaneous
Used in crafting recipe
Beacon
Decorative Blocks
Miscellaneous
Utility block like furnace
Detector Rail
Redstone
-
Directly activates redstone
Activator Rail
Redstone
-
Gets directly activated by redstone
Powered Rail
Redstone
-
Gets directly activated by redstone
Dispenser
Decorative Blocks
-
Utility block like furnace
Dropper
Decorative Blocks
-
Utility block like furnace
Trapped Chest
Decorative Blocks
-
Utility block like chest
Noteblock
Decorative Blocks
-
Utility block like furnace
Redstone Lamp
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
End Crystal
Miscellaneous
Decorative Blocks
Entity, not a block
Armor Stand
Miscellaneous
Decorative Blocks
Entity, not a block
Item Frame
Miscellaneous
Decorative Blocks
Entity, not a block
Painting
Miscellaneous
Decorative Blocks
Entity, not a block
Pumpkin Seeds
Miscellaneous
Materials
Can't be used in crafting recipes
Melon Seeds
Miscellaneous
Materials
Can't be used in crafting recipes
Wheat Seeds
Miscellaneous
Materials
Can't be used in crafting recipes
Beetroot Seeds
Miscellaneous
Materials
Can't be used in crafting recipes
Ghast Tear
Materials
-
Also used in end crystal recipe
Iron Horse Armor
Transportation
Miscellaneous
Used only on horses which are transportation
Gold Horse Armor
Transportation
Miscellaneous
Used only on horses which are transportation
Diamond Horse Armor
Transportation
Miscellaneous
Used only on horses which are transportation
Oak Door
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Spruce Door
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Birch Door
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Jungle Door
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Acacia Door
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Dark Oak Door
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Iron Door
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Wooden Trapdoor
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Iron Trapdoor
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Oak Fence Gate
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Spruce Fence Gate
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Birch Fence Gate
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Jungle Fence Gate
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Acacia Fence Gate
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Dark Oak Fence Gate
Decorative Blocks
-
Decorative
Slimeblock
Redstone
-
Used alongside sticky pistons (redstone people will also be very happy to not switch tabs to get this)
Wither Skeleton Skull
Materials
-
Used in various crafting recipes
Creeper Head
Materials
-
Used in various crafting recipes
Coal Ore
Decorative Blocks
-
Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
Iron Ore
Decorative Blocks
-
Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
Gold Ore
Decorative Blocks
-
Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
Diamond Ore
Decorative Blocks
-
Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
Redstone Ore
Decorative Blocks
-
Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
Emerald Ore
Decorative Blocks
-
Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
Lapis Lazuli Ore
Decorative Blocks
-
Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
Quartz Ore
Decorative Blocks
-
Not really used to build with in survival, more decorative
Jack o' Lantern
Decorative Blocks
Building Blocks
Used mostly for lighting, decoration (also remove the requirement for a block below to be present to be able to place, highly annoying)
Book Case
Decorative Blocks
Building Blocks
Mostly used for decoration
Coal Block
Decorative Blocks
Building Blocks
Decorative
Iron Block
Decorative Blocks
Building Blocks
Decorative
Diamond Block
Decorative Blocks
Building Blocks
Decorative
Gold Block
Decorative Blocks
Building Blocks
Decorative
Emerald Block
Decorative Blocks
Building Blocks
Decorative
Lapis Block
Decorative Blocks
Building Blocks
Decorative
(Wet) Sponge Block
Miscellaneous and/or Decorative Blocks
Building Blocks
Who builds with these... really?
Take a close look at the table below and decide which to change, hopefully most of them because they make sense, some of the bottom few are possibly more optional, but especially most of the top ones are highly recommended to change. It is sometimes a hassle to find an item quickly because of this. Most of the times, the search function is preferred cause of this.