The Bug
When I place an item frame on the ceiling, and an item in there, and then attempt to remove the item and the frame, both drop on top of the roof, instead of coming down from the ceiling. The roof/ceiling is one birch planks thick.
Steps to Reproduce
Build the setup as shown in the attachment below. setup.png
Switch into survival mode and destroy the item frame.
Take note as to whether or not the item frame is dropped above the diamond blocks or below them.
Observed Behavior
Destroying item frames and contents within them that are attached to ceilings drops the items above blocks.
Expected Behavior
Destroying item frames and contents within them that are attached to ceilings would drop the items below blocks.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 18
MC-134412
Item frame placed underneath block drops on top of block when broken
Resolved
MC-140682
Item frames don't drop from ceiling
Resolved
MC-141245
Itemframe flys through walls
Resolved
MC-145039
Item frames disappear on the bottom of blocks
Resolved
MC-151351
Items popped out of item frames placed on ceilings may phase through ceiling
Resolved
MC-156053
Items from item frames in ceiling doesn't drop. both item and item frame.
Resolved
MC-157323
Item in/and Item Frame drop wrongly when placed on ceiling of chests, that is to say facing downwards.
Resolved
MC-168680
Item frames, when in cealings, breaking them causes it to go upwards
Resolved
MC-171314
Item frames placed on the bottom of furnaces causing trouble
Resolved
MC-171802
Ceiling Item Frames going through the ceiling
Resolved
MC-177304
Item frames on ceilings don't pop off right
Resolved
MC-230300
Glow Item Frame doesn't drop when removed from ceiling block
Resolved
MC-259292
bug with item frame in ceiling
Resolved
MC-265607
Item frames on the ceiling don't drop items or the frame itself.
Resolved
MC-265794
Maps removed from overhead item frames disappear
Resolved
MC-270388
Item Frames Destroy Themselves
Resolved
MC-271905
Item frames and items inside it get catapulted through the ceiling when punched if item frame itself is on the ceiling
Resolved
MC-274651
since when you put an item frame on the ceiling and then want to remove it, it doesn't give you the item in survival.
Resolved
relates to 2
Attachments
Comments 36
Could you please remove the 18w01a from the title of your ticket?
Sounds fair enough? Probably relevant to whatever update added ceiling frames, too.
I should test backwards.
I duped this report for 1.13 (sorry Mods)
FWIW
I also tried this near Y=1. Placing an item frame on the bottom surface of the rock above and then breaking the frame causes the frame to float up through the solid blocks until it hits air. In my case, the natural surface at around Y=63
I wonder if a hopper placed up top would take the teleported item.
This is still an issue with 1.14 snapshots (currently with 18w49a). Removing the maps on item frames placed on the ceiling makes the map clipping through the roof. Attached screenshot: https://bugs.mojang.com/secure/thumbnail/192723/_thumb_192723.png
Can someone please check if that's still an issue in the latest 1.14 development snapshot? It might be fixed now I'm not sure.
Can confirm for the latest: 19w14a.
Can confirm for 1.14-pre2.
Can confirm for 1.14-pre5.
Can confirm for 1.14.
Confirmed for 1.14.1-pre2
Affects 19w37a.
Can confirm for 1.15-pre4.
Can confirm for 1.15-pre6.
Can confirm for 1.16.1
Can confirm in 21w03a.
Can confirm in 21w07a.
Can confirm in 1.16.5 and 21w08b.
Can confirm in 21w11a.
Can confirm in 21w13a.
Can confirm in 1.17.1.
I am able to confirm this behavior in 21w41a. Here are some extra details regarding this problem.
The Bug:
Destroying item frames and contents within them that are attached to ceilings drops the items above blocks.
Steps to Reproduce:
Build the setup as shown in the attachment below.
Switch into survival mode and destroy the item frame.
Take note as to whether or not the item frame is dropped above the diamond blocks or below them.
Observed Behavior:
Destroying item frames and contents within them that are attached to ceilings drops the items above blocks.
Expected Behavior:
Destroying item frames and contents within them that are attached to ceilings would drop the items below blocks.
Can confirm in 21w42a.
Video of the issue recorded on Minecraft 1.18.1 :
Can confirm in 1.18.2.
can confirm in 22w15a
Can confirm in 1.19 and 22w24a.
Can confirm in 1.19.2.
Can confirm in 23w03a.
still an issue in 1.19.4 and 23w12a
Added video for 23w12a
Also affects 24w14a.
Still an issue in 1.21.
The cause of this bug seems to be that items popping out of frames are always given a set velocity upwards. So when frames are under a block they get sent into that block and flung out randomly.
This mechanic is especially frustrating with item frames underwater because items are given a velocity upwards combined with the buoyancy of items means they always go rocketing towards the surface. Imgur video of the problem
Can confirm in 1.21.4.
Did some extra testing: This happens through at least three blocks.