mojira.dev
MC-130029

Water Doesn't Flow Correctly Near Fences, Etc.

When water is 5 blocks away from a drop (4 solid blocks, then air) with a fence (or other "water capable" block) between the water and the air gap, water will only attempt to flow in that direction before spreading out in all directions as it realizes that it can't actually flow across the semi-solid block.

However if it cannot flow in that direction at all (e.g another fence or other "water capable" block) then the water fails to flow at all and just sits there.

 

https://youtu.be/xq8OThjKHg0

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments

migrated

I heard water can flow out of waterloggable blocks but not flow in to them.
Possible WAI.

migrated

Oh, it totally makes sense that water can't flow into those blocks, but in the depicted situation the water SHOULD flow away through the opening. Placing a fully solid block instead of a fence causes that behavior, and if "water-capable" blocks can't be flowed into and treated as solid...

migrated

Minecraft doesn't have that coded in yet. That's why it doesn't work.

tryashtar

Michael, notice the screenshot. The water isn't flowing out the empty space, where it should flow even if the fences were solid blocks. And on that note, I cannot reproduce this.

migrated

Oh, my bad. I was able to reproduce this; Make a 3x3 square with fences, with 1 block air inside, then place the water bucket, breaking one of the fences afterwards.
It seems kinda random when it happens or not. It isn't random. You have to wait about 2 seconds after placing the water and then remove one of the fences.

[media]

migrated

Tryashtar: note that you need a place where water wants to "naturally flow downhill," ie, an air block no more than 5 blocks away and 1 down:

[media]

Torches being the stand-in for Fences/slabs/etc and the Lapis being where the water is.

 

Michael: no breaking of fences required. I'm talking about dropping a bucket down and expecting it to flow one way and having it not flow at all.

migrated

Agree, when tested on a 8x8 flat surface water behaved normally.

tryashtar

Ah, I can reproduce when there's a hole somewhere on a side except for directly in front of the opening. Thank you

migrated

Bingo

migrated

Ah ha, there was a duplicate. I tried to find it, but it eluded me.

migrated

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Minecraft 18w20c

Retrieved