mojira.dev
MC-1490

Zombie / Villager Zombie can't shoot bows.

When a zombie / villager zombie is given a bow, it will not shoot the bow but just walk towards the player and hit him with it, like the zombie was holding a sword or just attacking without any items equiped. I don't know if this is intended (Maybe zombie's are supposed to be so stupid they don't know how to fire a bow) but it's annoying if you have to use a skeleton instead. It's the same with other ranged weapons like snowballs.

Linked issues

Comments 10

My useless comment:
One could argue that they only grabed the bow, not the arrows...

Zombies can pick up any item, that does not mean they use it. If they pick up a cobblestone block, you don't expect them to place it either.
Or you could say, they have the bow, but are out of arrows.

I added arrows too. They still didnt shoot

They only pick up 1 item, don't they?

Anyway, I don't think using items is part of the zombie AI, so this probably works as intended.

I used a chest and a MCEdit filter to add the arrows. So it is possible.

btw about the mobs placing blocks:

I don't want that either. if all mobs could place blocks (lets call it "Endermanisation") your world would be completely destroyed in no time if you had the gamerule MobGriefing on. However i think it's different with tools. Giving zombies the ability to use a bow would never destroy your world (Unless you've got the Flame Enchantment and the arrow hits a big pile of TNT, but what are the chances of that happening) in any different way than a skeleton could. It would also be very usefull if they could throw other projectiles like eggs, snowballs and splash potions (Though witches have been added they only throw some specific potions) so you can make custom maps more challenging. (Diamond armor zombie with Punch XVII bow XD) I don't think the zombies should be able to destroy blocks with their tools (Also part of Endermanisation) but they should be able to use them in battle. I also noticed it works the other way around too. If you give a skeleton a sword (Or something else) it will still shoot arrows out of it. It's the exact same bug.

Works as intended - they aren't supposed to shoot bows. Zombies aren't known for their hand eye coordination.

Maybe the zombie thing isnt a bug.
The skeleton bug deffinately is. A sword shouldnt be uused to shoot arrows out of.

The skeleton thing is already reported under another issue.

When you put it into perspective, it makes sense.

What would you do if you were a zombie with 1/4th of the IQ of a archer?

Rob Klein Ikink

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

bow, zombie, zombie_villager

Minecraft 1.4.2

Retrieved