Hay Bales are crafted with 9 wheat.
According to http://www.minecraftwiki.net/wiki/Horses#Foods 1 wheat heals 1 heart, a hay bale heals 10 hearts which is nearly no mismatch.
But looking at how fast one can speed up the growth of a foal, there is a huge mismatch:
1 wheat = 1 minute
1 bread = 3 minutes
1 hay bale = 3 minutes, too
So you could speed up the growth of a foal with 3 bread by 9 minutes, but with 1 hay bale only 3 minutes, like with 1 bread, that is crafted with only 3 wheat ?
Logical conclusion:
Either the speed growth of a foal must be larger for a hay bale, or a hay bale should be crafted with 4 and not 9 wheat!
If you craft a hay bale with 4 wheat, then the speed growth rate of a hay bale could be set to 4 minutes, and for a golden apple then something more (up to you; at the moment a golden apple seems to speed up 4 minutes)
If the hay bale would be crafted with 4 wheat, then the amount of heart it heals must be reduced of course in the same step.
As 1 wheat heals 1 heart, it should heal 4 or 4.5 hearts then I suppose.
(1 wheat = heals 1 heart, 1 bread = heals 3.5 hearts)
Comments 12
Hello Kumasasa,
I'm new to this, so let me please ask you:
If the developers could have a future failure-free released 1.6 version, wouldn't they prefer that over a bugged or mismatches-containing 1.6 version ?
So if we players can show up all the possible problems or mismatches now in the snapshots, why is that not okay ?
How could we know the devteam knows about the problems and mismatches so they can fix it preferrably before the release ?
Why can others report bugs of "unreleased versions" then, but my mismatch is not okay to be reported ?
Sorry, I don't get that.
Thanks in advance for an explanation,
Meri
You can't mark a version as beeing affected without actually testing it since it is not released yet. If you see someone reporting a bug as affecting an unreleased version please tell us. We are here to make sure only valid versions available for public testing can be set as affected.
Hello Tails and Kumasasa, thank you for explaining!
The version being affected says "13w18c" though - but I cannot remember if that was me chosing it, or if one of you guys maybe changed it to that }😉
I will try out the mismatch eventually with 13w19a to confirm the mismatch one can read in the Minecraftwiki, and will remember to chose the correct affected version number if I'm opening or editing an issue.
Thanks again!
Nice weekend for you.
It's a problem with the tracker software (JIRA). The "Affects Version/s" field draws from the same list as the "Fix Version/s" field. They can't be controlled separately. They want the future version on that list so the developers can specify that something will be fixed in it, but that unfortunately means it also has to be an option in the "Affects version/s" box.
By reporting an issue, you're making it less likely to affect a future version. It doesn't make sense then to say "This definitely still affects a future version that doesn't exist yet", which is what including that future version in the "Affects version/s" box says. To aid the developers in tracking down the cause of a bug, and fixing it, you should only include versions that you have tested and experienced the bug in.
Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version 1.6.2 / Launcher version 1.1.3 ? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.
Will do as soon as I can @Tails, cannot get into the game at the moment, maybe until tomorrow, lots to do in real life.
According to mcwiki http://www.minecraftwiki.net/wiki/Horses#Foods it is still the same, but I cannot verify it currently - but, as I said, will do so asap.
Kind regards,
Meri
Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version 1.7.4 / Launcher version 1.3.8 or later? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.
Hello Alex,
I'll have a look into it as soon as possible, probably in 2 days, at latest this coming weekend, and I'll upload some screenshots or a small video proving it (I have a mod showing the process of foal growth etc.), so give me a bit - real life is being busy at the moment };]
Kind regards,
Meri
Please do not mark unreleased versions as affected. You do not have access to this yet.