Endermen don't pick up non collidable blocks

Thank you for your report!
However, this issue is Invalid.

Minecraft has several different editions, and some features vary from edition to edition. Often this happens when one edition evolves faster than another, and tweaks or balances are made that don't propagate immediately to other editions.

You have posted a feature request. This site is for bugs only. if you want to make a suggestion, please visit the feedback website, or Minecraft Suggestions on Reddit.

Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – 📖 Game Wiki

I didn't request this, it is a bug... I've tested it using a data pack: when I add mushrooms, flower pots and torches to the enderman_holdable tag, it doesn't work. When I assign blocks to the tag, endermen will only pick it up when you can collide with the block, and the block's collision shape contains the center point of the full block... However, they should pick up every block in the enderman_holdable tag, which is not the case...

I don't see a feature request in this though... It's on the wiki, and when I extract the default data pack from the jar file, it seems to be defined there too...

In the MCP remapped source code, in the take-block AI, there is this:

public void tick() {
         Random random = this.enderman.getRNG();
         World world = this.enderman.world;
         int i = MathHelper.floor(this.enderman.posX - 2.0D + random.nextDouble() * 4.0D);
         int j = MathHelper.floor(this.enderman.posY + random.nextDouble() * 3.0D);
         int k = MathHelper.floor(this.enderman.posZ - 2.0D + random.nextDouble() * 4.0D);
         BlockPos blockpos = new BlockPos(i, j, k);
         IBlockState iblockstate = world.getBlockState(blockpos);
         Block block = iblockstate.getBlock();
         RayTraceResult raytraceresult = world.rayTraceBlocks(new Vec3d((double)((float)MathHelper.floor(this.enderman.posX) + 0.5F), (double)((float)j + 0.5F), (double)((float)MathHelper.floor(this.enderman.posZ) + 0.5F)), new Vec3d((double)((float)i + 0.5F), (double)((float)j + 0.5F), (double)((float)k + 0.5F)), RayTraceFluidMode.NEVER, true, false);
         boolean flag = raytraceresult != null && raytraceresult.getBlockPos().equals(blockpos); // It's this rule that causes the bug
         // It should be: raytraceresult == null || raytraceresult.getBlockPos().equals(blockpos);
         if (block.isIn(BlockTags.ENDERMAN_HOLDABLE) && flag) {
            this.enderman.func_195406_b(iblockstate);
            world.removeBlock(blockpos);
         }
      }

Thanks for editing your ticket and clarifying the issue is about holdable tag. We will resolve this ticket as a duplicate of MC-145143.

If you would like to add a vote and any extra information to the main ticket it would be appreciated.

Given the obscurity of MC-145143 and the excellent detail of this report, I'm going to forward-resolve to this being the primary ticket. Thank you for your deductions.

Agreed. But @@unknown it would have been easier if you had added the relevant information when you created this ticket. At first, you were talking about parity update between bedrock and java, which is a feature request… Then you answered by coming to the fact with the holdable tag.

✔ Issue confirmed, description restructured and code analysis embeded.