mojira.dev
MC-156133

Small jungle tree has jungle_log and oak_leaves

I'm in a jungle biome (bamboo_jungle_hills) and the small trees all have oak_leaves. and drop oak saplings. Even if the log blocks are jungle_logs.

Linked issues

Comments 9

Please provide the seed and coordinates.

seed: 3109806141950473819 

coordinates around

X: -4055
Y: -3589

there are several small trees with only 1 jungle logs, that have oak leaves.

(i went there to get jungle saplings, and was surprised to get oak saplings, while i only had jungle logs in my inventory) 

I also tested this seed in 1.14.4 (by re-creating a new creative version of my world in 1.14.4) and there the same happens.

try another world does it happen there?

(X-Post from 16632)

I don't think this is "Works As Intended".

The trunk is JUNGLE wood log while the leaf is OAK wood leaves. 

And the leaves drops oak saplings???

 

I think the developers missed something here and the wiki played it as a feature of the jungle biome.

It should be JUNGLE wood log and JUNGLE wood leaves. (or OAK log and OAK leaves)

 

This is a different issue from MC-16632 in that that ticket was only about oak leaves dropping oak saplings, which is obviously intended.

This is a separate issue, but also very likely to be not a bug but intended, since the bushery in jungle biomes has been made out of oak leaves ever since jungle biomes are a thing.

Still in 1.15 snapshots. I think it shouldn't be intended, because tree with different log and leaves does not make any sense. It should be fixed.

Jungle bushes (small one log "trees") have always been made out of jungle wood and oak leaves. This is not a mistake and changing it would change the look and feel of the jungles.

This is so obviously a parity issue. 

Eric Smit

migrated

Community Consensus

World generation

Minecraft 1.14.3, 1.14.4, 20w17a

Retrieved