Ender Dragon doesn't take damage from melee attacks unless hit a certain way

Can i request ownership? user's last activity was august 2019.

in 1.15.2 there could be the problem where the dragon doesn't change state correctly, it will never activate the landing sequence.

Ric, if you want the ticket back you can ask a mod and i'll accept, i just requested ownership to keep updating the affected versions. And about the dragon hitboxes, that's probably being tracked as MC-111009.

Seems like only the head and tail hitboxes work properly, the torso works sometimes, I couldn't really figure out when. The wing hitboxes don't seem to work at all.
(Confirmed in 1.16.1, but that doesn't help.)

This seems very inconsistent. I have killed the dragon 3 times in the same game (survival, 1.16.2). The first two times the fight went normally. The third time, I hit the dragon once with my sword, and after that no further melee hits registered. I had to finish the fight using only bow and arrows.

Edit: 4th fight

I upgraded my game to 1.16.3 and set up another dragon fight. Initially my sword did damage, but then it stopped when hitting the rear end. Hitting near the front seemed to work a little longer. I re-logged mid-fight and the sword started working again briefly, before stopping again. After a second re-log the sword came back to life and I finished the fight.

Edit #2: Subsequent Fights

I have now killed the dragon 4 more times. Most of the time the fight proceeded normally. A couple of occasions hits from the sword stopped working. I used the workaround, wait til the dragon sits on the pedestal, re-log and then continue. Worked every time.

TLDR: this seems to be an intermittent problem. A (risky) workaround is to re-log while the dragon is on top of the pedestal.

These are the kinds of major bugs that baffle me when they're not fixed asap, while other trivial bugs are prioritized.

**Can confirm this bug first appeared in 19w08b, alongside many other serious bugs with the Ender Dragon that are still in the latest version. These issues include its hitbox, the way it descends to the fountain, and just its AI in general.

I'm pretty sure there's some kind of desync problem as sometimes when in creative you try to hit her (melee) you can't (with a weapon you see the Sharpness particles but no hit is registered).

EDIT: Found out MC-225055

With mods magic I've managed to summon at the actual position of the ender dragon's parts (head, neck, wings and tail) some angry villager particles. (Tested in singleplayer) As you can see the client sees the dragon there (both hitboxes and actual model) while on the server she's ahead.

The tail parts:

Finally after two hours of debugging I've found out why you can't hit the dragon sometimes. It has to do with where the dragon is (chunk wise) and where you're aiming at.

But first off, why can't you hit wings? Seems like they're swapped between client and server. So if right wing has Entity ID 1 and left wing has Entity ID 2 on the client, for the server it'll be Entity ID 2 for the right wing and Entity ID 1 for the left wing. With this the server thinks that you're hitting the far away wing so since there's a max range for the hit of 6 blocks you can't reach it and so the hit is registered on the client (MC-225055) but not on the server.

For the problems about not hitting her at all is a little bit more complicated.
The problem arises when you aim at any of the dragon's part: if you're aiming at the chunk in the direction where the center position of the dragon is you'll hit her, otherwise the hit will miss, that's because the ender dragon is not found in the chunks you're raycasting in so the hitboxes aren't checked at all.

Let's make an example.
Here the player, the ender dragon's head hitbox and the ender dragon position are all in chunk 0,0. When the player tries to hit the Ender Dragon's head he searches for the Ender dragon in Chunk 0,0 and -1,0 (the direction looking). The dragon is found in 0,0 so raycasts are made to find the head and in the end (pun intended), the attack lands, dealing damage to the dragon.

In this case the hit will not land as the Ender Dragon is searched for in chunks -1,0 and -1,-1, but she's in 0,0 thus not found, the finding of the head is not done and the hit fails.

"Why most of the times I can hit her while in the portal?"
Because the raycast actually starts from 2 blocks behind the player so most of the times 0,0 will be searched for the dragon.

While in this case your hitbox doesn't load 0,0 so the dragon is not found and the hits will not land

Note that in the examples the Ender Dragon center position is always in 0,0 but can be in any of the 4 chunks when slightly off.

Affects 21w42a

Maybe this issue is relative with that?

https://github.com/MinecraftForge/MinecraftForge/issues/8188

Can confirm in 1.19.3 pre3. I think you should add to the report that this bug (as well as other ender dragon bugs like its fountain descent and pathfinding) all appeared due to a fix in 19w08b.

Can confirm in 23w18a.

Can confirm in 1.20 release canidate 1

Can confirm in 1.20.1

Can confirm in 23w31a.

Can confirm in 23w32a.

Can confirm in 1.20.2

Can confirm in 23w40a

In 23w43a.

Can confirm in 23w51a/23w51b

Can confirm in 24w06a, affects wind charges

Confirmed in 24w07a

Just a reminder, you don't need to comment "affects version" everytime there's a snapshot out, you'll just spam emails to those watching the issue. Just confirm an affected version when there's a significant change or bugfix that could be related to this bug.