mojira.dev
MC-165750

Falling sand drop with half in the air because of the idbox

What I expected to happen was...:

In both situation, sand will return to a solid block

What actually happened was...:
only the falling block with a non-air under it will turn into solid block

Steps to Reproduce:

summon/place a falling block with something like 3/4 in air and 1/4 above a solid block (with a command block it's :   )

summon minecraft:falling_block ~ ~3 ~0.75 {Time:1}

and if next to the solid block there is :

  -block (torch, full block...) : sand turn it into solid block ✔

  -air : sand stay as a falling block and it drop ❌

 (note : I used the same setup as MC-165728 but it's only because I had found with this bugreport)

 

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 6

@unknown Can you clarify this report and provide a video or repro steps? When i try to reproduce, the sand is behaving as intended and slides down the honey without popping after being pushed with a piston. 

Oops sorry, it's not because of honey, i had placed a block under the honey, the sand stay in air.

(replace honey by fence and it doesn't change anything, we need just to create a falling block how isn't on a single block)

It's a little bit confused in my head, I had seen something strange but i don't know how to describe it.

[media]

Copy/pasting from @unknown 

"I used the same setup as in the video from https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-165728, with a solid block at the end of the pillar
It's important that the falling block is  pushed against the honey block's hitbox. It happens because the honey block has a collision box slightly lower than a full block, and only when the falling block is pushed against that collision box."

I can't reproduce this on multiple tries. As soon as an offset sandblock connects to an ordinary properly aligned block, the sandblock will pop. See the "Falling sand" video attached. 
@unknown Can you still reproduce this behavior on the latest pre release?

This might have been fixed in 1.15-pre1 along with MC-165727.

Edit: I'm unable to reproduce in 1.15-pre1 too.

Yes it's fixed, tanks (1.15 pre2 too)

Jiogo18

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

(Unassigned)

falling_block, honey-block

19w46b

1.15 Pre-Release 2

Retrieved