mojira.dev
MC-175975

Pine trees ("Matchstick" and "Lollipop" small spruce tree variants) can never be grown from saplings

Tried to grow some spruce trees from saplings and I never got matchstick or lollipop variants. This is inconsistent with oak trees - you can grow large and baloon oak from saplings.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 8

Honestly I think it'd be best if these variants were renamed to pine trees and given their own specific sapling and wood type.

I would try to get a bigger sample size for spruce trees and see if the problem is continuing to happen. (Edit) I would also try to see if "Matchstick" and "Lollipop" trees can spawn with saplings in taigas as that is probably the problem.

They can't. They only GENERATE in taigas

@unknown, that would be good. It would be a great addition to builders and also more biomes(old taigas being renamed to spruce taigas, pine taigas and taigas being the ones with spruces and pines).

[media]

place saplings in 2x2 for big trees. also apparently creates podzol when they grow

@unknown, that is not the point of this bug. The point is, these 2 variants of SMALL spruce trees are impossible to grow from saplings.

Can this ticket be renamed to refer to these trees as "pine trees", since this is what they are referred to in their json files, as well as what their tall 2x2 versions are referred to (see old growth pine taiga vs old growth spruce taiga)?

Affects 1.21.3. Also would like to request ownership of this report to maintain it

W_V

sof

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Block states

1.15.2, 20w12a, 20w13a, 20w13b, 20w14a, ..., 21w14a, 1.17.1, 21w40a, 1.21.3, 1.21.4

Retrieved