mojira.dev
MC-177529

Comparator doesn't recieve pulse from observer, but will if it is two observers simultaneously

Comparators do not normally receive one tick pulses from observers (this seems to either be a known issue or working as intended). However, If the same redstone line recieves two observer pulses on the same tick, the comparator will recieve and transfer the one tick pulse.

Using the setup pictured below, I confirmed that there seems to be no difference in the timing of length of the pulse whether there is one observer or two.

Steps to reproduce:

Create setup shown in screenshot. Update trapdoor above gold block once with only one observer connected, then again with two observers connected.

The two chat screenshots show the output of the three command blocks shown in the screenshot The dash indicates every game tick, the star indicates when the observer line is powered. Because there are only two stars this indicates that in both tests, it was a one tick pulse.

 

This seems different enough, but may be related to MC-109737 

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 2

Duplicate of MC-109737 - please search in future

According to @unknown on Discord, the second observer makes the an extended single tick, which is why MC-109737 doesn't apply in that case (and as such that would be working as intended). The fact that MC-109737 happens if there's only a single tick is already covered in MC-109737, so I resolved this ticket as a duplicate of MC-109737.

For reference: https://discordapp.com/channels/647810384031645728/648660584677769217/696640718449541161

Noah Adams

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

(Unassigned)

20w14a

Retrieved