The Bug
You are not supposed to be able to remove curses from any tool. But, if you use a cursed fishing rod to craft a warped fungus or carrot on a stick, the curses on the fishing rod are removed
Steps to Reproduce
Give yourself a fishing rod that has a curse on it.
/give @s fishing_rod[enchantments={vanishing_curse:1}]Obtain either a carrot or some warped fungus.
Craft either a carrot on a stick or warped fungus on a stick, using the fishing rod with the curse.
Take note as to whether or not fishing rods retain their curses when used for crafting carrots or fungi on sticks.
Observed Behavior
Fishing rods do not retain their curses when used for crafting carrots or fungi on sticks.
Expected Behavior
Fishing rods would retain their curses when used for crafting carrots or fungi on sticks.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 1
relates to 2
Attachments
Comments 19
Curses count as enchantments technically, though. Also, the item with the curse is being crafted into something else, so it is WAI.
On the other hand MC-158807 was fixed. So we will have to wait for a decision by the developers.
Can confirm this behavior in 21w42a. Here are some extra details regarding this problem.
The Bug:
Fishing rods do not retain their curses when used for crafting carrots or fungi on sticks.
Steps to Reproduce:
Give yourself a fishing rod that has a curse on it.
/give @s minecraft:fishing_rod{Enchantments:[{id:"vanishing_curse",lvl:1}]}Obtain either a carrot or some warped fungus.
Craft either a carrot on a stick or warped fungus on a stick, using the fishing rod with the curse.
Take note as to whether or not fishing rods retain their curses when used for crafting carrots or fungi on sticks.
Observed Behavior:
Fishing rods do not retain their curses when used for crafting carrots or fungi on sticks.
Expected Behavior:
Fishing rods would retain their curses when used for crafting carrots or fungi on sticks.
This should be WAI, right? as repairing enchanted things in the crafting grid removes enchantments