The Bug:
The bottom half of village wells can generate offset.
It appears that the "minecraft:village/plains/town_centers/plains_meeting_point_1" structure randomly rotates its bottom piece (from the jigsaw pool "minecraft:village/common/well_bottoms") and therefore 75% of the time, it will be positioned incorrectly.
Here is an example:
Version: 1.19.4
Seed: 5593159168574735956
Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:overworld run tp @s 10571.30 62.00 2040.70 571.87 -1.33Steps to Reproduce:
Generate a world with the seed provided above and teleport to the given coordinates.
Look closely at the generation of the village well.
Take note as to whether or not the bottom half of village wells can generate offset.
Observed Behavior:
The bottom half of village wells can generate offset.
Expected Behavior:
The bottom half of village wells would not be able to generate offset.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 9
MC-179468
Misplaced Part in Village wells
Resolved
MC-229296
Village fountain doesn't get generated the right way
Resolved
MC-231665
The bottom of the fountain of the plain villages is shifted
Resolved
MC-232839
Plains meeting point 1 generates wierdly
Resolved
MC-268107
Some "meeting point 1" structures in superflat worlds generate an extra pool
Resolved
Attachments
Comments 20
Confirmed in 1.21-pre3.
It looks straightforward to fix unless I am misunderstanding jigsaw blocks. Only two small changes to one file seem necessary.
The relevant file is
1.21-pre3.jar\data\minecraft\structure\village\plains\town_centers\plains_meeting_point_1.nbt1) Change the jigsaw with orientation:down_south (7th in palette) to orientation:down_north. This will then match the jigsaw in well_bottom.nbt, which is orientation:down_north.
2) Change its data (the one with state:6) from joint:rollable to joint:aligned to remove the randomness.
Hi there!
I can confirm this. I also can confirm this for the same seed at 7975 4999301.
Also can confirm on seed 6556390857611507720 at coordinates 5999420 4999960.
This only seems to happen with two-deep wells; same seed (6556390857611507720) coordinates 3999456 2999936 (a four-deep well) did not have this same issue.
The reason for the big coordinate numbers is because I tested the bug while teleporting to random coordinates and finding the closest village.