mojira.dev
MC-196459

Bowl recipe weirdness

The recipe for bowl only unlocks once one is crafted and not when the player gets planks

 

How to reproduce: Open a new world or use /recipe to remove the recipe

Pick up planks

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 5

As the recipe json clearly shows, the bowl is unlocked when mushrooms are picked up.

Since the mushroom isn't required to make the actual bowl I suggest that the json is wrong and this is a bug. You craft a bowl using 3 wood planks.  Mushrooms have nothing to do with the crafting of it.

You need a bowl to make beetroot stew which doesn't use a mushroom at all.  You can also use a bowl on a mooshroom cow to get mushroom stew, and you can burn bowls as fuel. They are indepedent items from mushrooms and therefore should not be waiting until you get a mushroom to open the recipe. There are 3 bugs filed with this as an issue so I'm guessing the community thinks it's a bug.

 

There are 3 bugs filed with this as an issue

Could you please link them? I am unable to find any about this issue.

This one, and:

MC-118416

MC-172271

Interestingly the 118416 bug says "Fixed".

MC-118416 concerns the fact that you used to need a bowl to unlock the bowl recipe, which was fixed. MC-172271 is actually the parent report of this, I did see it before - I will reresolve this ticket as a duplicate of that.

FredTheNerd

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

(Unassigned)

1.16.1

Retrieved