with the way this is going to be implimented it will cause a HUGE downfall for minecraft which not only will push away players and creators thus causing less content to be made but also harm the sales of future projects and existing projects. Yes there may be a problem with the fowl language and harmful behaviour that happens on servers but that is better done (by the looks of things) by the server admins as they will be able to see the full context, and even be able to share the names of problematic people with other server admins, not only this but banning them from singleplayer worlds? are you out of your mind?
Comments 6
This site is for bug reports only, for feedback on features, go to the feedback site.
Additionally, you don't seem to understand what kind of reports are and aren't accepted. This is added for behavior that violates the community standards only; swearing isn't against it, hate speech and grooming are.
These reports don't belong here, nor is their creation appreciated by Mojang, the volunteers, or the users of Mojira. You're just creating clutter!
Please, leave.
the suggestions site links to "help centre" and "bugs" which is here, so theres nothing there, as for the subreddit due to a stupid claim that "mojang arent allowed to add mods to the game" (which is bull cause youve added mods to the game before, stained glass, pistons, potions apparently too, and so many more) i've got a ban from there, and if i were to make an alternate account to circumvent the ban any accounts that are used on the same IP would get banned taking from the Reddit rules
the way the system is presented it looks like an automatic system that if it behaves like other automatic systems then a group of people could mass report 1 account that they dont like which would result in a ban from both multiplayer and singleplayer, further to this do you not know how common it is for an account to get compromised? reach out to the staff at hypixel and ask how many accounts have been compromised since they have been running, seeing as its one of if not the biggest server (that isnt 2b2t) i wouldn't be surprised if its a lot, so that brings up the point how can you tell the difference between the owner of the account grooming and spreading hate speech and someone who is using the account that got accsess to it illigitimatly
and another thing on the way that it looks to be set up, there doesnt seem to be an appeal system to prevent the unlawful bans due to someone getting the account compromised, and it also looks like it will only affect servers running 1.19.1+ which there are still servers that are running versions of minecraft pre microsoft take over (which yes isn't good for them but seeing as how hated 1.9 was its unsurprising) so how will this new system work with older servers? like could the entirity of 2b2t be wipped from existence because of this (seeing as they are running 1.16 at the latest)
finally what is wrong with working with server owners like the hypixel crew to actually make a list and system to ban people legitimatly? as stated they most likely already have a community where they have lists of players who have like a traffic light system Green- not on the list, a good player, Yellow- On the list keep an eye on these people, Red- Ben them before they have a chance to get on the server.
Am i defending racists and nonces? no, but any system that is automated is flawed, and the fact you cant see that honestly startles me
oh and you should also check out that subreddit you told me to check out cause guess what https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/comments/vdrp6n/please_read_minecraft_reporting_feature/ no posts about the report feature to be made, there isnt even a post to post suggestions and complaints about it, almost as if the team doesnt care
See MC-253436 for additional context. I just wanted to address some of the points you're making:
the way the system is presented it looks like an automatic system that if it behaves like other automatic systems
It's a bad idea to assume how the system works and then complain about it based on those assumptions. I recommend reading through the Chat Reporting FAQ and similar articles on minecraft.net to gain a better understanding of how the system works.
would result in a ban from both multiplayer and singleplayer
Only multiplayer functions are disabled. For more information, check out the articles mentioned above.
and another thing on the way that it looks to be set up, there doesnt seem to be an appeal system to prevent the unlawful bans due to someone getting the account compromised
Again, instead of making assumptions based on headlines, I would recommend reading the articles published by Mojang. This would then reassure you that there is indeed an appeal system.
That's.. not a bug. That's feedback. If you want to add feedback go to Minecraft's feedback website.
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue is Invalid.
You have posted a feature request or a suggestion. This site is for bug reports only.
For suggestions, please visit Minecraft Suggestions on Reddit or visit the Feedback website.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Game Wiki