mojira.dev
MC-262106

Smithing recipe must have template to work

Recipes for the smithing table (added through datapacks) which do not include an item to use as the smithing template do not work.

This breaks several datapacks and makes frankly very little sense.

How to reproduce:

  • Download the attached datapack

  • Create a new test world which uses the attached datapack. (The datapack includes new recipes for netherite tools which are the same as vanilla but without the template)

  • Try to make a netherite sword, shovel, axe, pickaxe, hoe or helmet by placing the diamond equivalent and a netherite ingot in the smithing table (do not include a smithing template) --> It will not produce an output.

None of the recipes will work, even if they're included in the datapack. I included multiple recipes because each one of them uses a different syntax to achieve a template-less recipe, but, as you can see, none of them work.

Attachments

Comments 2

Please give me the data pack for this issue, it's easier than to create it.

@Brain81505 Hi, you're right, I attached a datapack to be used in 20w17a, it includes new recipes for netherite shovel, pickaxe, axe, hoe, sword and helmet, all using different methods to try and get them to work with no template. (all of them are just the vanilla recipe minus the template).

ArrotinoD

mattiasselin

Confirmed

Expansion A

Important

Crafting, Data Packs

23w16a, 23w17a, 23w18a, 1.20 Pre-release 1

1.20 Pre-release 2

Retrieved