The Bug:
Trapdoors and doors have inconsistent subtitles for being opened and closed.
Affected Subtitles:
Before reading the tables, please note the following:
Characters colored in GREEN are correct and show consistent behavior.
Characters colored in RED are incorrect and show inconsistent behavior.
Trapdoor Type | Open Sound | Open Subtitle | Close Sound | Close Subtitle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Oak | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Spruce | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Birch | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Jungle | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Acacia | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Dark Oak | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Mangrove | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Cherry | minecraft:block.cherry_wood_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.cherry_wood_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Bamboo | minecraft:block.bamboo_wood_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.bamboo_wood_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Crimson | minecraft:block.nether_wood_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.nether_wood_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Warped | minecraft:block.nether_wood_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor creaks | minecraft:block.nether_wood_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor creaks |
Iron | minecraft:block.iron_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor opens | minecraft:block.iron_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor closes |
Copper | minecraft:block.copper_trapdoor.open | Trapdoor opens | minecraft:block.copper_trapdoor.close | Trapdoor closes |
Door Type | Open Sound | Open Subtitle | Close Sound | Close Subtitle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Oak | minecraft:block.wooden_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_door.close | Door creaks |
Spruce | minecraft:block.wooden_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_door.close | Door creaks |
Birch | minecraft:block.wooden_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_door.close | Door creaks |
Jungle | minecraft:block.wooden_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_door.close | Door creaks |
Acacia | minecraft:block.wooden_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_door.close | Door creaks |
Dark Oak | minecraft:block.wooden_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_door.close | Door creaks |
Mangrove | minecraft:block.wooden_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.wooden_door.close | Door creaks |
Cherry | minecraft:block.cherry_wood_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.cherry_wood_door.close | Door creaks |
Bamboo | minecraft:block.bamboo_wood_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.bamboo_wood_door.close | Door creaks |
Crimson | minecraft:block.nether_wood_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.nether_wood_door.close | Door creaks |
Warped | minecraft:block.nether_wood_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.nether_wood_door.close | Door creaks |
Iron | minecraft:block.iron_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.iron_door.close | Door creaks |
Copper | minecraft:block.copper_door.open | Door creaks | minecraft:block.copper_door.close | Door creaks |
h3. Steps to Reproduce:
Ensure that you have subtitles enabled.
Place down a copper door and a copper trapdoor.
Open and close them both and pay attention to the subtitles that are displayed.
Observed Behavior:
Iron and copper trapdoors have unique subtitles for being opened and closed, which is inconsistent.
Expected Behavior:
Iron and copper trapdoors would display the "Trapdoor creaks" subtitle upon being opened and closed, therefore maintaining consistency.
Attachments
Comments 3
This may or may not be a bug. The fact that they are both ore and not wooden trap doors is a big difference. There are two possible things happening here. One, the copper trapdoor and iron trapdoor sounds are a bug, or two, they are not a bug and the iron door and copper door were accidentally given the same sounds as the wooden doors. This is confirmed though, so there is no doubt that there is a bug somewhere, be it with the trapdoor or the doors.
Can confirm in 23w45a