This behavior was introduced in 25w34a.
The bug
If you encounter an error while trying to recreate a world and go back to the world list, all worlds temporarily lose their world icon and use the default one instead. Once the world list is reopened, the custom world icons are shown again.
Steps to reproduce
Obtain a world that cannot be recreated in the version to reproduce the issue in. For 1.21.11, a world created in 26.1-snapshot-6 or a later version can be used.
Launch the version to reproduce the issue in.
Ensure that at least one world in the world list has a custom world icon.
Attempt to recreate the world obtained in step 1. An error will occur as expected.
Click Back to return to the world list.
Observed behavior
All worlds in the world list will display the default world icon, including those that have a custom icon.
Expected behavior
The worlds with a custom icon would display that icon, as was the case in previous versions.
Thank you for helping us improve Minecraft! We saved your files: