mojira.dev
MC-311737

Inventory block shading still does not match pre-1.15

Relates to MC-262869.

From release 1.0.0 up to 1.14 (close to an entire decade), the shading of blocks in the inventory remained just about constant - if a block used a fully white texture, the top would be #FFFFFF, the left would be #A2A2A2, and the right would be #6F6F6F.

1.15’s rendering reforms ultimately broke this (MC-213446) - even if an item was fully white in texture, it would be rendered subtly pale gray in the inventory at most.

The darker item issue was silently fixed in 26.1, meaning that the top face is now white as it should be, however there are still differences in how the left and right faces are shaded.

To reproduce this issue, I’ve attached a texture pack for 1.0.0 and resource packs for 1.14.4 and the latest snapshot that turn cobblestone entirely white, which can be used to reproduce this issue:

  • download and apply the texture pack in 1.0.0, obtain cobblestone, take a screenshot (in a chest as the player’s inventory renders items slightly darker until 1.4 for some reason)

  • download and apply the resource pack in 1.14.4, obtain cobblestone, take a screenshot

  • download and apply the resource pack in the latest version, obtain cobblestone, take a screenshot

  • compare the colour values of cobblestone in all three screenshots

Expected results: the top face would be #FFFFFF, the left would be #A2A2A2, and the right would be #6F6F6F, reverting 1.15’s broken item rendering entirely and restoring the expected, previous behaviour.

Actual results:

  • 1.0.0: #FFFFFF (correct), #A2A2A2 (correct), #6F6F6F (correct)

  • 1.14.4: #FFFFFF (correct), #A2A2A2 (correct), #6F6F6F (correct)

  • 26.3-pre2: #FFFFFF (correct), #A5A5A5 (WRONG), #666666 (WRONG)

Attachments

Comments 1

Thank you for helping us improve Minecraft! We saved your files:

[media][media][media][media][media][media]

muzikbike

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

26.2, 26.3 Pre-Release 2

Retrieved